Brother guilt-trips unpaid carer role for mum
Brother guilt-trips unpaid carer role for mum

A 49-year-old marketing director who works from home says his brother is pressuring him to reduce his working hours to care for their 79-year-old mother unpaid, and has called his request for compensation ‘mercenary’.

Gary, who lives in York and earns £85,000 a year, told Metro’s consumer champion Sarah Davidson that his mother has become much less independent after a fall earlier this year. She lives alone and needs help most days. Gary lives 15 minutes away, while his brother is about an hour’s drive from her.

He says his brother seems to think that because he works from home full time, he can go round to their mum’s whenever she needs something. Gary said he cannot keep dropping everything to collect prescriptions, pop to the shops or help her work the television. Their mother refuses to have carers because she does not want ‘strangers’ in the house.

Brother suggests three-day week

Gary’s brother has suggested he drop to a three-day week, arguing that Gary’s husband earns well and they could manage. Gary proposed that if he is expected to give up actual earnings, his brother should contribute towards the cost. His brother said paying him to look after their own mother would be ‘mercenary’. Their mother overheard and cried.

Gary said he feels awful and that his brother knows he will do it because ‘she’s our mum and I love her’, but he feels the arrangement is unfair.

Consumer champion’s response

Sarah Davidson said Gary’s brother sounds ‘both selfish and manipulative’, noting that both sons are equally responsible for their mother. She pointed out that dropping from five to three days a week on £85,000 would reduce Gary’s income by £34,000 a year before tax, and he would also lose employer pension contributions and the growth that investment is likely to generate.

Davidson advised Gary to get a free care needs assessment from his mother’s local council’s adult social services department, which should distinguish practical care needs from things a family member can help with occasionally. She also suggested asking the council for his own carer’s assessment and speaking to his employer, noting that the law allows him to request flexible working, although approval is not guaranteed. Statutory carer’s leave provides up to one working week unpaid in each 12-month period.

She recommended negotiating family contributions if he genuinely wants to reduce his hours, putting any paid care arrangement in writing, and arranging a face-to-face meeting with his brother and his partner if he has one. Davidson also suggested involving their mum in the decisions and gently explaining to her: ‘I love you and I’ll keep helping, but I cannot leave work whenever something comes up. We need support that works when I’m unavailable.’

She added that the brother can organise care enquiries and take responsibility for scheduled visits, as an hour’s drive does not prevent him handling paperwork or appointments.