The latest UK Competitiveness Index shows Wales remains one of the least competitive economies in the UK, with Blaenau Gwent ranked as the worst performing local authority area out of 349 assessed.
The index, led by academics at Cardiff University's City Region Co-Lab, Birmingham City University and Nottingham Trent University, ranks economies on ten input and output measures, including business start-up rates, the share of knowledge-based firms, employment rates, higher-level qualifications and GVA per head.
Little change since devolution
Comparing the 2026 index with the earliest comparable figures from 1997 shows how little has changed. In 1997 Wales was the second least competitive region of the UK, ahead only of the North East of England. In 2026 it remains second least competitive, still ahead only of the North East.
Blaenau Gwent is again ranked at the bottom of the index, as it was in 1997. Also in the bottom ten are Merthyr Tydfil (347th) and Rhondda Cynon Taf (341st). The index does show some progress, with Blaenau Gwent's score rising from 68.3% of the UK average in 1997 to 72.5%, and Caerphilly's (ranked 325th) rising from 74.9% to 79.7%. In the 2023 index, Wales recorded the largest improvement of any region in the average competitiveness of its localities.
These gains have not been enough to change Wales' position relative to the rest of the UK. In 1997 just one Welsh local authority, Monmouthshire, scored above the UK average; in 2026 just one, Cardiff, reaches it.
City region rankings
On the index's ranking of 47 core cities, Cardiff is ranked 13th, Newport 31st (with a score of 89.6) and Swansea 41st (85.1). Of all 349 local authority areas, Cardiff is the highest in Wales at 101st, followed by Monmouthshire at 137th and Flintshire at 158th.
Of 47 local enterprise partnership areas and city regions, the Swansea Bay City Region is ranked bottom, with Mid Wales second lowest in 46th. North Wales is also in the bottom ten in 41st place. The Cardiff Capital Region is ranked 37th.
In 2026 Wales scores 85.6 against the UK average of 100, down from 86.2 in 2022. London (114.9) and the South East (102.4) remain the only regions above the UK average. Swansea Bay City Region is the least competitive with a score of 83.1, followed by Mid Wales (84.0), while the Cardiff Capital Region slipped from 88.8 to 87.9.
Wider economic evidence
The findings are consistent with wider evidence on the Welsh economy. Early post-devolution economic plans set the goal of raising GDP per head in Wales to 90% of the UK average by 2010; instead, it had fallen to 69% by 2008. In 2023, GVA per head in Wales was 72.2% of the UK average, the second lowest of the UK's nations and regions, and household income per head has fallen from 88% of the UK level at its peak in 2003 to 81% in 2023.
Report lead Professor Robert Huggins, director of the City Region Co-Lab at Cardiff University, said: "I take no pleasure in talking Wales down, but the evidence has to be faced. The UK Competitiveness Index has tracked Wales for almost the entire life of devolution, under largely Labour-led governments, and the story it tells is stark. Almost thirty years and a succession of economic strategies later, Wales is exactly where it was."
He added: "Policy has failed at every geographic level. Nationally, Wales has not moved the dial relative to the UK as a whole. Regionally, its city regions are among the least competitive in Britain. And locally, the same communities sit at the foot of the table as they did a generation ago."
Cardiff's limited spillover
Cardiff, the most competitive locality in Wales, scored 99.7 in 1997, just below the UK average, and scores 100.0 today. Professor Huggins said: "Cardiff is the shining light of the Welsh economy, but given the scale of investment it has received, and the economic spillovers it should be enjoying from a growing Welsh Government on its doorstep, it should be shining far brighter. A capital city that has barely moved on our index in almost thirty years has not been economically transformed."
The report's forecasts point to widening gaps within Wales. Monmouthshire is forecast to have the fastest growth in GVA per capita in Wales (1.6% a year), while Merthyr Tydfil, in the same city region, has the weakest forecast of any locality in Britain, with GVA per capita falling by 0.9% a year.
Professor Huggins said: "Too little of Cardiff's success is spilling over into the communities around it. On current trends, the gaps within the city region are set to widen, not close."
The report identifies a shortage of knowledge-intensive businesses as Wales' central weakness. These make up 8% of businesses in Swansea Bay, against a UK average of 22.7%. Wales also has the highest proportion of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) of any part of the UK, despite the Welsh Government having had a framework to reduce the number of NEET young people in place since 2013.
Professor Huggins said: "A strategy that has been in place for more than a decade but still leaves Wales with more of its young people outside education, employment or training than any other part of the UK, is not working. Alongside a chronic shortage of the knowledge-intensive businesses that create well-paid jobs, that is a failure we cannot keep repeating."
The Plaid Cymru Welsh Government has set out plans for a National Development Agency for Wales and a Wales Wealth Fund, with a focus on building and retaining wealth in Welsh communities. It has also set a target of halving Wales' workplace productivity gap to half of the UK average. Latest figures from the ONS show that output per head in Wales is around 85% of the UK level.
Professor Huggins said: "I hope the new government can begin to turn this around, and its focus on building wealth in Wales is the right one. But you can't retain wealth you haven't generated. A wealth strategy has to stretch from improving the prosperity of our most deprived communities to the individuals and firms best placed to invest in growing Welsh businesses. Wales needs both if prosperity is to be built, not just shared. Wales cannot afford to remain an isolated regional economy within an increasingly isolated national economy. It needs to connect with the networks of investment, knowledge and talent that drive growth elsewhere."