In response to Dave Schilling's article questioning the appeal of cruises, readers have shared their own positive experiences, defending the holiday choice and highlighting its unique benefits.
Accidents Happen, But Care Is Excellent
Christine Gawthorpe from Stafford recounts breaking her wrist twice before planned cruises to Iceland. While the first incident led to cancellation after a grueling NHS ordeal, the second occurred onboard. She was swiftly treated by charming doctors in naval uniforms, given ketamine for pain, and taken to her cabin by wheelchair, enjoying the rest of her trip. She advises Schilling to make lemonade from lemons, rather than staying in bed to avoid risk.
Medical Support at Sea
Pauline Cowen from Derbyshire describes catching COVID on a Fred Olsen cruise shortly after restrictions lifted. She and her husband were isolated in a balcony cabin with free wifi, library books, and daily chef calls for meal choices and wine. Medics checked on them regularly, and they recovered by the time they returned to the UK, feeling better looked after than at home.
Variety and Hygiene
Mary Graham from Maryland notes that not all cruises are the same—some are large, some small. She highlights that hygiene is taken seriously, with handwashing arranged before meals. For those who dislike packing every morning, staying in the same cabin while moving locations is much easier. She also suggests Schilling learn to swim, as many have overcome similar fears.
Claire Reynolds from Hertfordshire points out that a cruise offers extended time with family, such as an elderly mother, which may be unavailable on land. She advises booking it now.
Stuart Samuel from Denbighshire quotes Billy Connolly's description of cruises as 'prison, with the option of drowning,' adding a humorous counterpoint.
