Higher Price Does Not Guarantee Ethical T-Shirt, Experts Warn
Higher Price Does Not Guarantee Ethical T-Shirt, Experts Warn

Paying more for a T-shirt does not necessarily mean it is ethically made, according to experts who study fashion supply chains. While a very low price can be a warning sign, a high price tag does not guarantee fair wages for workers, sustainable materials, or better treatment of animals.

Gordon Renouf, co-founder of the website Good on You, which rates brands on ethical and environmental practices, said: “Our ratings show that price is not a reliable indicator of ethical production. Many luxury and premium brands charge significantly more without demonstrating evidence of that value flowing to workers or environmental practices.” Dr Eleanor Scott, a lecturer at the University of Leeds, added that higher retail prices often go towards branding, marketing, and retailer margins rather than better labour or environmental standards.

Research by the University of Leeds and the Waste Resource Action Programme found that price had no bearing on durability. Of the top ten best-performing T-shirts tested, six cost less than £15, outperforming many more expensive versions, including one costing £395.

However, experts caution that extremely cheap T-shirts are unlikely to be ethical. Renouf noted that “a £3 or £5 T-shirt cannot accommodate living wages and responsible materials sourcing.” Ellie Gaffney of the Better Cotton Initiative said: “If a price point feels too good to be true, it probably is.”

Some affordable brands do achieve high ethical ratings. Yes Friends, a UK brand rated “great” by Good on You, sells basic T-shirts from £12. Renouf explained that such brands achieve competitive pricing through large-scale production, low margins, and direct-to-consumer sales. Other highly rated UK brands include Rapanui (£18), Brothers We Stand (£20), THTC (£30), and Not Basics (£29.99).

Emma Nicholas of the Good Shopping Guide found that some highly rated companies sell T-shirts at similar prices to lower-rated rivals. For example, activewear brands Sweaty Betty, Tala, and Lululemon all start at £30-£35, but Tala scores 88 out of 100 for ethics, while Lululemon scores lower. Experts advise consumers to research brands thoroughly rather than relying on price alone.