Aldi cheddar beats Cathedral City and Pilgrims in Which? taste test
Aldi cheddar tops Which? taste test over Cathedral City

Aldi's Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar has been named the best extra mature cheddar in a Which? blind taste test, beating well-known brands such as Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice.

The consumer champion gathered 75 cheese lovers to sample 11 extra mature cheddars, including eight supermarket own-brands and three branded options. Aldi's cheese took first place with an approval rating of 78%, and was also awarded a Great Value accolade, priced at just £2.99 for 350g.

Top Scorers and Best Buys

Three quarters of tasters felt the Aldi cheddar's colour looked just right, and a similar proportion were won over by its smooth, firm and creamy texture. Julie Ashfield, chief commercial officer at Aldi UK, said: "We're delighted to see our Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar recognised by Which? as a Best Buy. We know how important quality and value are, particularly at Christmas, and this award is a fantastic result for our team. At just £2.99, shoppers can enjoy an award-winning cheddar that delivers on both taste and value, making it a great addition to any festive cheeseboard."

Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar, priced at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g), also received a 'Best Buy' rating with a score of 76%. Testers praised its smooth, creamy and salty qualities. Waitrose Davidstow Cornish Extra Mature Cheddar also earned a 'Best Buy' at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g), securing a 75% approval rating, with tasters won over by its salt levels and creamy texture.

Other Favourites and Lower Scores

Cathedral City Our Extra Mature Cheddar scored 74% at £3.50 for 350g (£1 per 100g), with tasters appreciating its appearance, saltiness and smoothness, though some preferred a slightly stronger flavour and crumblier texture. Morrisons also scored 74%, with most applauding its firmness, saltiness, creaminess and level of crumble, though a third felt it crumbled a little too much. Sainsbury's Taste The Difference Extra Mature Cumbrian Cheddar scored 74% at £3.95 for 350g (£1.13 per 100g), with just over a third of tasters feeling it lacked sufficient crumble, though it boasted an appealing appearance and robust flavour.

Lidl's cheese, priced the same as the Aldi favourite, scored 73%, with testers appreciating its appearance, smoothness and creamy texture, and a large majority feeling salt levels were spot-on. Asda Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset Extra Mature Cheddar scored 72% at £3.52 for 300g (£1.17 per 100g). Marks & Spencer Cornish Cruncher Extra Mature Cheddar scored 70% at £5.25 for 300g (£1.75 per 100g), and Castello Tickler Extra Mature Cheddar scored 69% at £4.50 for 300g (£1.50 per 100g).

Tesco came bottom with 66% and was among the more expensive choices at £3.50 for 200g (£1.75 per 100g).