Aldi's Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar has been named the best extra mature cheddar in a Which? blind taste test, beating well-known brands such as Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice.
The consumer champion gathered 75 cheese lovers to sample 11 extra mature cheddars, including eight supermarket own-brands and three branded options. Aldi's cheese took first place with an approval rating of 78%, and was also awarded a Great Value accolade, priced at just £2.99 for 350g.
Top Scorers and Best Buys
Three quarters of tasters felt the Aldi cheddar's colour looked just right, and a similar proportion were won over by its smooth, firm and creamy texture. Julie Ashfield, chief commercial officer at Aldi UK, said: "We're delighted to see our Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar recognised by Which? as a Best Buy. We know how important quality and value are, particularly at Christmas, and this award is a fantastic result for our team. At just £2.99, shoppers can enjoy an award-winning cheddar that delivers on both taste and value, making it a great addition to any festive cheeseboard."
Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar, priced at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g), also received a 'Best Buy' rating with a score of 76%. Testers praised its smooth, creamy and salty qualities. Waitrose Davidstow Cornish Extra Mature Cheddar also earned a 'Best Buy' at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g), securing a 75% approval rating, with tasters won over by its salt levels and creamy texture.
Other Favourites and Lower Scores
Cathedral City Our Extra Mature Cheddar scored 74% at £3.50 for 350g (£1 per 100g), with tasters appreciating its appearance, saltiness and smoothness, though some preferred a slightly stronger flavour and crumblier texture. Morrisons also scored 74%, with most applauding its firmness, saltiness, creaminess and level of crumble, though a third felt it crumbled a little too much. Sainsbury's Taste The Difference Extra Mature Cumbrian Cheddar scored 74% at £3.95 for 350g (£1.13 per 100g), with just over a third of tasters feeling it lacked sufficient crumble, though it boasted an appealing appearance and robust flavour.
Lidl's cheese, priced the same as the Aldi favourite, scored 73%, with testers appreciating its appearance, smoothness and creamy texture, and a large majority feeling salt levels were spot-on. Asda Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset Extra Mature Cheddar scored 72% at £3.52 for 300g (£1.17 per 100g). Marks & Spencer Cornish Cruncher Extra Mature Cheddar scored 70% at £5.25 for 300g (£1.75 per 100g), and Castello Tickler Extra Mature Cheddar scored 69% at £4.50 for 300g (£1.50 per 100g).
Tesco came bottom with 66% and was among the more expensive choices at £3.50 for 200g (£1.75 per 100g).