With Christmas just over five weeks away, the season of cheese boards is approaching, and a new blind taste test has crowned a supermarket own-brand as the best extra mature cheddar. Consumer champion Which? gathered 75 cheese lovers to try out 11 extra mature cheddars, pitting eight supermarket own-brands against three name-brand options.
The test revealed that Aldi's Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar outperformed Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice to be named the champion, with an approval rating of 78%. It is also a Great Value cheddar, costing just £2.99 for 350g.
Aldi's winning cheddar
Three quarters of tasters thought the cheddar's colour looked the part, and a similar proportion were won over by its smooth, firm and creamy texture. Julie Ashfield, chief commercial officer at Aldi UK, said: "We're delighted to see our Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar recognised by Which? as a Best Buy. We know how important quality and value are, particularly at Christmas, and this award is a fantastic result for our team. At just £2.99, shoppers can enjoy an award-winning cheddar that delivers on both taste and value, making it a great addition to any festive cheeseboard."
Another cheese classed as a 'Best Buy' in the test was Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar, priced at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g). It scored a 76% from testers, with cheese-lovers appreciating the smoothness, creaminess and saltiness of the cheese.
Other Best Buys and favourites
Waitrose Davidstow Cornish Extra Mature Cheddar was another 'Best Buy' at £4.25 for 350g (£1.21 per 100g) and an overall approval rating of 75%. Tasters liked the salt levels and creamy texture of this cheese.
Cathedral City Our Extra Mature Cheddar, at £3.50 for 350g (£1 per 100g), had a 74% approval, with tasters appreciating its appearance, saltiness and smoothness; however, some said they would like a slightly stronger flavour and crumblier texture. Morrisons The Best Extra Mature Farmhouse Cheddar, £3.50 for 300g (£1.17 per 100g), also earned a 74% score, with the majority praising its firmness and saltiness, though a third found it crumbled too much.
How the rest scored
Sainsbury's Taste The Difference Extra Mature Cumbrian Cheddar, £3.95 for 350g (£1.13 per 100g), scored 74%, but just over a third of tasters thought it was not crumbly enough, although it looked good and had a strong flavour. Lidl Deluxe Somerset Crunchy Extra Mature Cheddar, £2.99 for 350g (85p per 100g), matched the Aldi favourite on price but scored 73%, with tasters approving its appearance, smoothness, creamy texture and salt levels.
Tesco scored the lowest with 66% and was one of the pricier options at £3.50 for 200g (£1.75 per 100g). Asda Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset Extra Mature Cheddar, £3.52 for 300g (£1.17 per 100g), scored 72%; Marks & Spencer Cornish Cruncher Extra Mature Cheddar, £5.25 for 300g (£1.75 per 100g), scored 70%; and Castello Tickler Extra Mature Cheddar, £4.50 for 300g (£1.50 per 100g), scored 69%.