Asda Extra Special Greek Koroneiki Extra Virgin Olive Oil has been crowned the best supermarket olive oil for 2026, outperforming popular brands like Filippo Berio. A food critic from The Independent conducted a comprehensive taste test, sipping and dipping through supermarket own-label and non-supermarket offerings.
Priced at £8, the Asda oil is made from 100% Greek olives and delivers a ripe, fruity flavour with subtle spicy undertones. The critic praised its depth and intensity, noting a 'rocket-like peppery finish' and a balanced, rich taste ideal for Greek salads.
In second place came Aldi Specially Selected P.D.O Castel Del Monte extra virgin olive oil (£5.49), followed by Belazu early harvest extra virgin olive oil (£13.50) in third. Filippo Berio Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil (£10) placed just behind.
Last year, a separate tasting by our Senior Lifestyle reporter Angela Patrone gave Asda's own brand eight out of ten, but her top spot went to Waitrose Extra Virgin Olive Oil, which scored a perfect ten. She described it as subtle yet peppery with a smooth aftertaste, ideal for salads, though at £8.50 per litre it is pricier.
Olive oil sommelier Mazen Assaf advises choosing oils in tin or dark glass bottles to protect against heat, oxygen, and light. He recommends single-origin oils from specific regions and checking for the olive variety on the label to ensure authenticity.