Ospreys hit back at WRU plan as report defends finances
Ospreys hit back at WRU plan as report defends finances

The Ospreys have defended an independent report they commissioned into the Welsh Rugby Union's plan to cut a professional team, insisting it did assess financial factors and shows the proposal is "not grounded in evidence".

The club said the report, produced by experts at Sheffield Hallam University, comes as the WRU continues with its plan to reduce the number of teams to three by 2028. With Cardiff and Dragons set to be safe if they accept licence terms, the Ospreys appear to be competing with local rivals Scarlets for the final spot.

Report findings on finances

Earlier this month, the Ospreys commissioned Sheffield Hallam University to produce a report on the issues facing Welsh rugby. In publicly announcing the report and its findings that a team should not be culled, it did not initially address financial figures.

However, the Ospreys have now clarified that Welsh rugby finances are covered in the report, adding that it shows any savings made in cutting a team do not cover the WRU's current losses.

"Losing a club would halve the Welsh derbies that draw almost half of league crowds, the Sheffield Hallam report finds," said an Ospreys statement. "In the WRU's own documents this is a choice about how money is allocated by our governing body."

The Sheffield Hallam report is said to estimate that reducing the number of teams would save £6m a year, concluding any changes "would not address the £18.1m deficit the WRU accrued in 2024, 2025 or 2026".

WRU's position

The WRU is adamant the game in Wales cannot financially support four equally funded teams going forward, with the union recently recording the £18m loss, and a similar result expected next year.

The union's strategy is focused on concentrating talent and ploughing millions into a new national academy system it says will deliver the elite Welsh rugby players of the future. The union does not claim cutting a team would fully address its huge losses but insists it has to find ways of saving money, with its planned restructure one of those.

WRU CEO Gavin Marshall recently said after news of the £18m loss emerged: "We need to cut the amount that we're spending on professional rugby because we're making a significant loss and even though I'm ambitious and I can see growth and I know we'll improve, we've got a long way to go to improve by £18m."

"So I think from my perspective we can't afford the level of distributions that we're making."

High turnover but big losses

The Ospreys said the report also highlights how WRU turnover has risen by £21.9m since 2022, yet over those five years, the WRU have recorded a pre-tax loss in four of them. It added that the Irish Rugby Football Union funds four provinces on a lower union income - €98m (about £82m) in 2025.

"Turnover has reached a record level in each of those years, yet a loss was recorded in four of them," said lead author of the report, Dr Steve Bullough. "On those figures, a £6m saving would not address the deficit."

"Almost half of WRU income comes from the men's national team, and reducing the domestic game is unlikely to improve that revenue base."

Dr Bullough reiterated that Welsh derbies account for almost half of league attendances in Wales, with a three-team structure halving the number of fixtures. "Removing a club would mean fewer Welsh supporters attending professional matches and fewer elite playing opportunities in Wales," he said. "That is not likely to raise interest in the national team.

"Putting a figure on that cost would need a full economic impact assessment, which we have not seen."

Earlier this year, the WRU commissioned the Keystone report, which it said provided data to back their decision to cut a team. "Keystone ranks the clubs on revenue volume, while noting that all four posted losses," the Sheffield Hallam report stated. "Revenue on its own is not a sufficient measure of financial sustainability.

"A proper comparison needs a consistent set of indicators: profit and loss, cost base, investor benefactor dependence, commercial income, attendance and stadium utilisation. We looked at the WRU data pack, the Keystone report and our own secondary analysis. Taken together they do not logically lead to the conclusion removing a professional team is grounded in evidence."

WRU's published evidence

The WRU has previously published a new microsite that hosts progress reports, detailed documents and supporting evidence behind its future operating model for the men's professional game in Wales.

A WRU statement said: "The site provides gathered data, reports and historical information, charting the path Welsh rugby has taken to establish its current strategic direction, summaries of WRU plans and evidence it has used to support its decision-making process to date.

"Included is the most recent externally commissioned independent analysis looking at data relevant to the location of new licences from the 2028-29 rugby season. Openness and transparency throughout the transition to the new operating model is a vital part of the process for the WRU's board.

"The site also provides a comprehensive timeline and briefing on how the new licensing process will be shaped."

Ospreys director Roger Blyth says that the "arithmetic is there for anyone to read and points to a potential £6m saving against an £18.1m loss". "It is important all the evidence is on the table before a club is lost, and at the Ospreys we are determined to share that evidence with supporters and the Welsh public," added Blyth.

"In the WRU's own documents this is a choice about how money is allocated by our governing body. It has always been the case since the decision to geographically cut a club in West Wales made in October 2025 and enhanced in July this year, with no proper clear evidence as to why as confirmed by this report.

"Welsh supporters have made it clear they do not want to lose a club. This is not about one club against another. We want four clubs, and we want Cardiff, Dragons and Scarlets alongside us. Everyone in Welsh rugby wants a game that pays its way.

"The question the report asks is whether taking a club away gets us there, and what it costs in derbies, crowds and players."

Dr Bullough added that he was willing to present the analysis and answer questions from any interested party, with the Ospreys set to hand the report in full to the WRU by the end of the month.