The Record Sport team has tackled the burning questions surrounding Steve Clarke's departure as Scotland manager, with opinions split on his World Cup approach and the hunt for his successor now underway.
Successor Search: Foreign Flavour or Familiar Face?
Craig Swan argues the SFA must conduct a thorough search rather than plucking a name from the sky, noting a foreign manager is appealing due to a lack of available Scots. Robbie Copeland advocates for proven international experience, suggesting Kasper Hjulmand, who led Denmark to the Euro 2020 semi-finals, as an ideal candidate. Gavin Berry believes Ange Postecoglou, known for his exciting brand of football from his Celtic days, would be a fan favourite, though wages and his current appeal remain obstacles. David Moyes is also mentioned but considered a likely financial stumbling block.
Clarke's Legacy: Triumph and Frustration
The panel reflects on Clarke's near seven-year tenure. Swan says it should be remembered with pleasure for three qualifications, though he acknowledges that's not how it works. Copeland predicts a fonder memory over time, noting Clarke left the job in a better place and provided unforgettable memories. Berry credits Clarke for ending Scotland's international wilderness but criticises his failure to progress at tournaments, adding that the time was right for him to leave due to growing negativity.
Criticism of Clarke: 'Absolute Disgrace' or Fair Game?
Kris Boyd's claim that criticism of Clarke was an 'absolute disgrace' draws mixed reactions. Swan agrees the criticism has been over the top but defends everyone's right to an opinion. Copeland concurs, stating some moans were well over the top throughout Clarke's tenure. Berry notes that excessive criticism comes with the territory but adds that Clarke's post-match interviews didn't help his case.
Gary Neville's Claim: Did Scotland Lack Quality to Attack?
Gary Neville argued Scotland lacked the quality to 'have more of a go' at the World Cup. Swan agrees, saying the idea of taking the handbrake off is fanciful, though Clarke may have been too cautious in the first two games. Copeland disagrees, pointing to the Morocco game where Scotland used two left-backs and refused to change even after conceding early, questioning why players like Ben Gannon-Doak or Findlay Curtis weren't given a chance. Berry also disagrees, highlighting Scotland's Premier League talent and Scott McTominay's Ballon d'Or shortlist inclusion as evidence they could be more adventurous.
