Why Man Utd should sell Bruno Fernandes and sign Morgan Gibbs-White
Why Man Utd should sell Fernandes and sign Gibbs-White

The arrival of Mauricio Pochettino as Manchester United manager should allow the club to make a fresh start, and parting ways with captain Bruno Fernandes could be the boldest move of his tenure.

The new boss has not been appointed as a continuity candidate, and there is already talk that he will be given reinforcements in January, something the owners have generally been reluctant to allow given their views on the mid-season market.

Fernandes' Legacy and the Case for a Sale

Since January 2020, Fernandes has been the biggest success story in terms of incomings at Old Trafford. While there is debate over which other players have improved since moving to the club, there is no argument over the skipper, and without him things could have been even worse.

Despite this, now could be the perfect time to say goodbye and move him on. This is not mainly about the former Sporting star's rant after the defeat away to Como in October, as a new set-up in the dugout should allow players to draw a line under the Michael Carrick era.

Instead, the focus should be on both the present and the future. 2027 might be the last year United can recoup a decent sum for Fernandes, but to justify a sale they need to be confident they are not losing a load-bearing midfielder.

Gibbs-White as the Ideal Replacement

To do that, they need to make the right signing when it comes to replacing him, and the clear leading candidate is Nottingham Forest star Morgan Gibbs-White.

The England international has already shown his leadership qualities at the City Ground, having captained the side regularly last season with club captain Ryan Yates rarely in the starting XI, and he has worn the armband in eight of the 10 league games under Oliver Glasner this term.

He also possesses a level of mobility and versatility which would allow him to operate in areas where Fernandes is less useful. Ruben Amorim made a point of feeling he couldn't use the skipper in the same midfield as Kobbie Mainoo, while a midfield pivot of Youri Tielemans and Andrey Santos was found out all too easily under Carrick, but Gibbs-White has shown he has the qualities to operate as a 10 or in a deeper role.

Dropping Fernandes into a three wouldn't solve that problem, but Gibbs-White, a younger and more energetic player with a combative streak when he needs it, could fill the role in a new-look system under Pochettino.

Cost and Balance Concerns

Some might feel Gibbs-White does not have the consistent star quality United's captain has shown at the sharp end of the pitch, but this season has demonstrated the importance of a team's balance, and balance feels far more urgent for a team currently facing a relegation battle before they can even start thinking about European qualification.

Gibbs-White might not come cheap: Transfermarkt values him at £66m, but with a contract running until 2028 and players of a similar calibre moving for north of £80m last summer, Forest may well feel they can demand more.

When buying proven Premier League quality, you should be ready to pay a premium, as last summer's signings demonstrated that pushing for the cheaper option can be a false economy. He is also at a good age, turning 27 in January, which means United can still get several years of him at the peak of his powers.

This is not to say Gibbs-White's arrival would be a magic bullet. Fernandes and team-mate Lisandro Martinez weren't exactly wrong when highlighting the wider issues at Old Trafford. This is not a squad which was bolstered to the necessary degree for a season in Europe, and given their current standing in the Champions League, there may well be an extra couple of games in that particular competition.

By offloading Fernandes at the end of the year and landing the right replacement, ideally Gibbs-White but if not then a player with a comparable profile, Pochettino can begin the process of turning United into a serious side once again, with plenty more changes needed.