Scotland's Pocognoli faces Switzerland selection questions
Scotland's Pocognoli faces Switzerland selection questions

Scotland head coach Sebastien Pocognoli faces several big selection calls before his side takes on Switzerland, with the Record Sport jury weighing in on the key decisions. The Belgian boss has been urged to consider changes to his starting lineup after a mixed start to his tenure.

Should Ben Gannon-Doak start?

Keith Jackson believes Gannon-Doak should start as an out-and-out winger in a different formation, but doubts Pocognoli will change his approach. "That's not going to happen," Jackson said. "Pocognoli will stick to his three at the back signature style and if Gannon-Doak starts at wing back then the Belgian will be asking for more trouble than he's already in." He expects Aaron Hickey to run the right-hand side with Gannon-Doak on the bench.

Scott McDermott agreed that if the manager sticks to his preferred 3-4-2-1 system, Gannon-Doak does not start, with Hickey at wing-back and Gannon-Doak used as an impact substitute. Mark Pirie said the winger should be benched if Scotland keep the same formation, noting Hickey and Nathan Patterson can cover at right wing-back, but added that Gannon-Doak must be on the right flank if the team switches to a front three.

Back three and midfield decisions

On whether Pocognoli will keep the same back three that played against North Macedonia or bring in Jack Hendry, Jackson said the back three has been "a pick and mix since the Belgian took over at the start of this campaign," calling it "probably part of the problem." McDermott suggested Hendry may still be out of favour after being red-carded against Switzerland at Hampden, so the same back three will likely stay. Pirie said Luke Graham could use an experienced head like Hendry alongside him, but Ryan Porteous has given the boss something to think about after his recall.

On Ryan Christie, who is pushing for a start after scoring against Slovenia, Jackson said no, describing Christie as "a fine and reliable Scotland player" who will have to wait while Pocognoli fits Billy Gilmour, Lewis Ferguson, John McGinn and Scott McTominay into midfield. McDermott said Christie has been "slightly harshly treated" and it is now a toss-up between him and Gilmour. Pirie said Christie has earned a look-in and could help anchor the midfield in St Gallen, with Ferguson a possible change in the engine room.

Assessing Pocognoli's start

Jackson said Pocognoli's start has been "far from perfect," with the promised new-look, front-footed Scotland side delivered only in sporadic patches. He said a big win and a joined-up performance against Switzerland is required before the next qualification campaign.

McDermott acknowledged teething problems are expected with a complete change in tactical approach and formation, adding that Pocognoli needs time and the players seem to have bought into his ideas. By March, he said, the boss should know his strongest 11 and stick to it. Pirie said it has not been pretty but it is not time to hit the panic button, given the absences of McTominay and McGinn during his tenure. "The hope is that something clicks and we can clearly see what Pocognoli imagines his Scotland side looking like - because I don't think we have seen it so far," he said.