Paul Scholes Champions Carlo Ancelotti for Manchester United Managerial Role
Manchester United icon Paul Scholes has publicly endorsed Carlo Ancelotti as the perfect choice for the club's next permanent manager, casting uncertainty over interim boss Michael Carrick's long-term prospects. Scholes made these remarks during a recent podcast appearance, highlighting Ancelotti's extensive experience and man-management skills as critical assets for the Red Devils.
Scholes Questions Carrick's Trophy-Winning Pedigree
Despite Michael Carrick's impressive start as interim manager, Scholes has raised significant concerns about his former teammate's ability to secure major silverware. Carrick, who took over earlier this year, boasts a joint-best record in Premier League history for a manager's first seven games, with six victories and one draw. This run has propelled United to third place in the league standings, strengthening their grip on a top-five position.
However, Scholes emphasised the distinction between short-term success and long-term trophy-winning capability. He pointed out that while Carrick has previous head coaching experience with Championship side Middlesbrough from 2022 to 2025, managing Manchester United presents a vastly different challenge. Scholes questioned whether Carrick possesses the necessary experience to win the Premier League, a doubt he also harboured about former manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.
Ancelotti Touted as the Ideal Candidate
Scholes identified Carlo Ancelotti, currently managing the Brazil national team, as the standout candidate for the role. He described Ancelotti as "the perfect one for Manchester United", citing his proven track record of winning trophies and his ability to make players feel valued. Ancelotti, who previously managed Real Madrid, is set to lead Brazil at the upcoming World Cup this summer.
Scholes expressed hope that United could lure Ancelotti away from his international duties post-tournament, though he acknowledged the potential hurdle of age, pondering if the Italian might be considered too old for the position. He stressed the need for a manager with a commanding presence and leadership qualities, attributes he believes Ancelotti embodies.
The Tactician Versus Man-Manager Debate
Scholes delved into the broader managerial philosophy United must adopt, framing it as a choice between a master tactician and a man-manager. He noted that Solskjaer excelled in man-management but lacked the tactical experience to win trophies, a pattern he fears could repeat with Carrick. Scholes suggested that successful man-managers often rely on brilliant coaches alongside them, such as Steve Holland, who works with Carrick.
The club's decision-makers now face a pivotal choice: opt for a tactician, which has previously failed, or seek a balanced leader who can both inspire players and deliver silverware. Scholes' comments underscore the high stakes involved in appointing a long-term boss, with the summer expected to bring clarity on Carrick's future and potential new appointments.
