Pochettino's Chelsea record assessed as Man United manager
Pochettino's Chelsea record assessed as United boss

Mauricio Pochettino has been appointed as the new Manchester United manager, but some Chelsea supporters have already delivered a critical verdict on his time at Stamford Bridge. Fans who never fully warmed to the former Tottenham boss have compiled what they see as a comprehensive list of errors from his 2023/24 season in charge, dubbed the 'Poch Files'.

Football.London's Chelsea writer Bobby Vincent, the Mirror's chief football writer John Cross, and the Manchester Evening News' United writer Steven Railston have addressed these criticisms, which range from the ridiculous to the credible.

Criticisms and responses

One criticism is that Pochettino started Ben Chilwell at left-wing for five games. John Cross responded: "That was weird… but at least he ditched it as it was part of their slow start."

Regarding the sale of Lewis Hall to Newcastle, Bobby Vincent noted that Pochettino would not have had much say in the departure, as the club's sporting leadership team had more influence over transfers. The pure profit appeal of selling Hall convinced the club's chiefs.

On the loan of Ian Maatsen to Dortmund when there was no left-back, Vincent again pointed to the sporting directors having more say than the head coach, with Behdad Eghbali and Todd Boehly both involved in transfers.

Results and player development

Steven Railston commented on United's need for Pochettino to start well, given the team's position in the relegation zone. He said: "I would be shocked if United don't enjoy a new-manager bounce."

On the claim that Pochettino didn't develop any players, Vincent highlighted that he gave Alfie Gilchrist 17 appearances across the season. Gilchrist was popular with fans, who called him 'Proper Chels'. However, Vincent noted that Pochettino barely used other academy players, partly because Chelsea had no European football, so rotation was not always a priority.

John Cross dismissed the claim that Pochettino played Enzo Fernandez as a striker, saying if it happened, it was due to an injury crisis, as Nicolas Jackson was the main striker.

Attacking style and player usage

Bobby Vincent rejected the claim of no attacking patterns of play, citing Cole Palmer's 42 goal involvements and Nicolas Jackson's 23 goal involvements in 2023/24. Malo Gusto also ended the campaign with nine assists, with full-backs providing width in the final third.

Regarding the claim that Conor Gallagher and Raheem Sterling started every game, John Cross noted that Chelsea spent £50m on Sterling and wanted him to play, but seven players played more than Sterling's 2,757 minutes. Gallagher topped the list of most minutes played by Chelsea players in 2023/24 and had his best-ever season.

On the record against the 'Big Six', Vincent said Pochettino's record was not awful but had too many draws. He noted a 4-1 defeat at Anfield and a 5-0 loss at the Emirates. Pochettino won 28% of his matches against 'Big Six' sides at Spurs (53 games, 15 wins, 15 draws, 23 defeats) and 30% at Chelsea (10 games, three wins, four draws, three defeats).

Player power and transfer influence

Steven Railston addressed the claim that Pochettino was told to change the system by players, noting this could be a problem at United given hints of player power. However, he said he couldn't imagine player power being a problem for Pochettino.

On the claim that Pochettino didn't integrate academy players, Railston said his record at Tottenham of giving young players opportunities speaks for itself, and he would expect United talent Shea Lacey to want to work with him.

Regarding the claim that Pochettino won fewer points per game than Graham Potter, Bobby Vincent said Pochettino left with a win rate of 47.4% in the league (38 games, 18 wins), while Potter's was 41.7% (24 games, 10 wins), so the claim isn't true.

John Cross dismissed the claim that Pochettino was one of the worst managers in Chelsea's history, noting the team finished sixth, reached the League Cup final and the FA Cup semi-final. He said: "This is nonsense - it was a better season than many."