Newcastle United should keep the door open for the potential return of club-record signing Nick Woltemade to the club next season. That is the view of former Magpies forward Dwight Gayle, although he concedes unless Matthias Jaissle changes the way he sets up his teams then the Germany international forward may not be the answer for Newcastle's troubles in front of goal.
Woltemade's St James' Park Start and Dip
Woltemade enjoyed a fantastic start to life at St James' Park, scoring nine goals across his first three months on Tyneside after completing a move from Stuttgart last summer. But the goals dried up in 2026 and Eddie Howe moved him back into midfield as he decided Woltemade did not have the physical qualities he desired from his centre-forward.
It was a conclusion Jaissle clearly came to, as well, with Woltemade failing to impress in the opening couple of games of the season and as United chased a deal to sign Lille's Matias Fernandez-Pardo, Woltemade's season-long loan move to Juventus was sanctioned.
Revival at Juventus
Woltemade took nine matches to score his first Serie A goal for the Old Lady but did score in each of his first three Europa League matches, becoming only the third player in Juventus history to score in his first three European matches for the club. The 24-year-old was named Juve's October Player of the Month, too, and with Newcastle's forward options struggling in front of goal - Yoane Wissa and Will Osula have one goal to their name this term, while Fernandez-Pardo is yet to find the back of the net for the Magpies - it has led to calls for Woltemade to return to Tyneside next season.
Juventus do not have an obligation to buy Woltemade in the loan deal and the message from Tyneside is that the door remains open for Woltemade to return to St James' Park. And while Gayle feels that is the right thing for all parties, he is unsure Woltemade will thrive on Newcastle while Jaissle prefers a more physical profile up front for his 'vertical football' philosophy.
Gayle's Verdict
"He's been having a great start to the season and he's a very good player and obviously brought into Newcastle because he was that but it all just depends on what the club and manager wants to play," Gayle told Chronicle Live via UK bingo sites. "If we're playing high intensity football or running in behind and you want your striker to do that then he might not be the answer for that reason. But at the same time even when he wasn't doing that last season he was scoring goals so that's obviously one of the hardest things to do in football and he was able to do that on a regular basis."
"It's not my decision to be the person to decide that but I'm really glad he's doing well and hopefully he can come back [to Newcastle] do well again."