Newcastle midfield dilemma: Jaissle's options and formation debate
Newcastle midfield dilemma: Jaissle's options and formation

Newcastle United manager Matthias Jaissle is still searching for the right combinations across the pitch, but in midfield he is spoiled for choice. With injuries clearing up, £35m summer signing Aladji Bamba did not even make the bench at Fulham last time out, as places in the engine room are at a premium under Jaissle's preferred 4-2-3-1 set-up.

Former Manchester City midfielder Nico Gonzalez appears to be the lynchpin, but Sean Steur, Lewis Miley, Jacob Ramsey, Joe Willock, and Bamba are all competing for places, with Joelinton set to add to the mix when he recovers from injury. The question is how Jaissle gets the best from that talented group, and whether he needs to change formation to do so.

Lee Ryder: Stick with two holding midfielders but make tough calls

Lee Ryder believes Jaissle has been stubborn with his midfield plans, sticking with two holding midfielders and refusing to return to the 4-3-3 system Eddie Howe used throughout his time at St James' Park. Ryder notes that going back to 4-3-3 could spark fears that Newcastle 2.0 has stalled, but fans won't care if the team is winning.

Jaissle has already suggested that Nico Gonzalez and Sean Steur won't be the preferred partnership in the double-six area. Ryder points out that Howe had Sandro Tonali and Bruno Guimaraes to choose between for the 6 and 8 roles, with Joelinton also deployed as the enforcer. He suggests Newcastle tick along nicely when Joelinton is fit and in form, but the other two positions would likely be filled by Lewis Miley as the technician, with a tough choice between Steur and Gonzalez.

Sean McCormick: Switch to a three-man midfield

Sean McCormick would switch to a three-man midfield until Newcastle sign a natural number 10 tailored to Jaissle's system. He believes Gonzalez would be better in that setup, playing in the quarterback role, with Steur and Miley, who he calls the future of Newcastle's midfield, alongside him.

McCormick notes that Steur and Gonzalez proved they could play together in Saturday's 1-1 draw with Fulham, while Miley, when fit, deserves a run in the team and has the legs and technical ability to excel in a three-man midfield.

Stuart Jamieson: Use the talent in a three, but leave Joelinton out

Stuart Jamieson finds it odd that Jaissle uses a system which restricts how many players can feature in the engine room, given midfield is probably Newcastle's strongest area in terms of squad talent. The No 10 role is not working in the current formation, and although he would not mind seeing Jacob Ramsey given a chance there, he believes United are better off going back to a three for now.

Jamieson still feels Gonzalez can be an important player, but he has to have bodies around him, with pace not his strong point. He has vision and technique that can flourish in the right system. Miley and Steur can be the future for Newcastle, and Jamieson sees no reason why they cannot play alongside Gonzalez in a three-man midfield, offering support at both ends of the pitch. Ramsey and Joe Willock can fit into that system with ease, but Jamieson would prefer to see the two youngsters given a chance to strike up a relationship on the pitch.

As for Joelinton, Jamieson says he is not in his preferred side.