Manchester United defender Luke Shaw has issued a passionate and emotional rebuttal following stinging criticism from club legend Roy Keane in the wake of their dismal 3-0 derby defeat to Manchester City.
The England left-back admitted the former captain's brutal assessment of the team's performance "hurt" him personally, but he insisted the players must take collective responsibility for the humiliating loss at Old Trafford.
A Scathing Assessment from a Legend
Speaking as a pundit on Sky Sports, an exasperated Roy Keane did not hold back in his post-match analysis. He lambasted the United players, claiming they were "not at the level" of their city rivals and accusing them of a lack of leadership and fight.
Keane's most cutting remark questioned the very character of the squad, suggesting they were "not up for the fight" and that such performances were becoming a recurring theme.
Shaw's Fiery and Emotional Riposte
When asked about Keane's comments, Shaw gave a revealing and honest response, acknowledging the pain they caused but also using them as a catalyst for a wider point about the team's mentality.
"Of course it hurt me," Shaw stated. "He was a fantastic player for the club, he knows what it takes to win and be at the top. But we have to take responsibility. We are on the pitch. The players have to be accountable."
The defender refused to hide from the performance, admitting City were "levels above" United and that the result was a stark reality check for everyone involved with the club.
A Call for Unity and Accountability
Shaw's response was notable not just for its raw emotion, but for its clear message of accountability. He shifted the focus from external criticism to the internal standards required at a club of United's stature.
"We have to look at ourselves in the mirror. Are we doing everything we can? Are we training hard enough? Are we doing the right things?" he questioned, setting a challenge for himself and his teammates.
This public airing of frustration and call for higher standards highlights the mounting pressure on the entire squad and manager Erik ten Hag to turn their faltering season around after a series of disappointing results.
