Everton's long-running search for a new right-back continued into the summer transfer window, eventually ending with the deadline-day signing of Ainsley Maitland-Niles. However, after a handful of below-par performances, the former Arsenal player now finds himself third in the pecking order at Goodison Park.
The club had been looking for a successor to Seamus Coleman for several years. Since Tony Hibbert's departure in 2016, Everton had signed only two senior right-backs: Cuco Martina on a free transfer and Nathan Patterson for £12m. Ashley Young also arrived on a Bosman deal, while Jonjoe Kenny came through the academy, but none were deemed suitable to become Coleman's long-term replacement.
Summer Transfer Window Struggles
With Coleman retiring this summer and Patterson sold on transfer deadline day, the need became pressing. David Moyes first identified Guela Doue as his target, but Everton considered Strasbourg's £40m asking price too steep. Doue eventually joined Bayer Leverkusen in an initial €30m deal. The Blues then failed to agree a deal with Celtic for Alistair Johnston.
Speaking at the end of August, Moyes admitted Everton had made several attempts to sign a right-back. "Look, we have identified quite a few right-backs we like, we have bid for quite a few we like," he said. "We are right in there - we are working to try and get one." He cited injuries, rejections, and clubs wanting higher fees as the main obstacles, adding, "I think there might be five or six managers before me who are trying to bring in a right-back as well, so I'm not the only one."
Maitland-Niles' Mixed Start
With the search going down to the wire, midfielder Merlin Rohl was tasked with playing out of position at the start of the season after joining permanently from Freiburg in a £17m deal. On transfer deadline day, Everton finally signed Maitland-Niles from Lyon in a £4.2m deal.
His debut was promising, coming off the bench to score a stoppage-time equaliser against Manchester United. He then helped the Blues keep three successive clean sheets against Tottenham Hotspur, Wolverhampton Wanderers and Ipswich Town, before claiming an assist in a 2-2 draw at Hull City. However, he was at fault for Hull's opener after Sorba Thomas intercepted his poor pass.
Current Right-Back Situation
Maitland-Niles was replaced after 55 minutes in a 2-0 defeat to Chelsea, soon after being partly at fault for Everton falling behind. He has not appeared in the Premier League since, watching on as an unused substitute for the last three games as Rohl returned to right-back and Jake O'Brien stepped in for the 1-0 away win at Newcastle United.
From being, at best, Everton's third-choice right-back target in the summer, Maitland-Niles now finds himself third in the pecking order. Time will tell if he can force his way back into favour as the festive period approaches, but just being able to play the role has not been enough for Moyes.