Jamie Carragher has warned Manchester United about Mauricio Pochettino's 'recurring issue' of failing to win the biggest matches in his previous jobs. United have turned to Pochettino, 54, following their worst-ever start to a Premier League season, languishing in the relegation zone after 10 games.
Pochettino's Record Under Scrutiny
The Argentine arrives with a reputation of improving young players and raising his teams' physical output, but also with a lack of trophies and a short lifespan in roles since he left Tottenham in 2019, such as at Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea. Carragher believes that Pochettino should be 'grateful' for United's decision, noting that the club turned him down on previous occasions.
"Although the United States impressed as World Cup hosts, (Manchester) United are not turning to Pochettino because of his international management career," Carragher wrote in his column for the Telegraph. "In 2025 his side lost to Panama in the Concacaf Nations League semi-final, and Mexico in the Gold Cup final.
"A recurring issue with Pochettino, which continued with the US team, is an inability to get over the line in the most consequential, winnable matches, resulting in a lack of big trophies.
Debate Over Spurs Legacy
"An ongoing debate centres on whether his work at Spurs deserves to be acclaimed for the manner in which he built a side who were in contention to be English and European champions, or scrutinised more critically because they won nothing."
The Liverpool legend does, however, feel that Pochettino and United are well matched for each party's circumstances. Carragher added: "The most successful relationships are often built on good timing. If United and Pochettino thrive together, a mutually beneficial alliance born out of circumstance rather than grand design might finally bring stability to Old Trafford.
"Pochettino could not have imagined such an opportunity to achieve what he could not manage during his first two stints in the Premier League: evolving from a brilliant coach into an elite one who can win the biggest trophies.
First Test at Liverpool
"The Argentine returns to England with a big reputation, but not enough on his CV to back up glowing testimonials. This must be one of his motivating factors - the chance to end any sniping and justify the claims of those who are adamant he is one of the most talented coaches of his generation.
"It is indicative of how Pochettino's career was going, and how quickly football's landscape can change, that United overlooked his claims for the job on previous occasions."
Pochettino faces a baptism of fire in his first outing as United manager. On Sunday, the Red Devils travel to Liverpool bidding to win only their second league game of the season.