Bruno Guimaraes' representatives always insisted they wanted the Brazilian international to leave through the 'front door' at St James' Park, but the midfielder's £75million move to Arsenal has left some fans unforgiving.
The 29-year-old had been open to signing a contract extension at the start of 2026, but doubts crept in about the club's direction and sporting project as Newcastle slipped out of contention for competitions one by one, culminating in failure to qualify for Europe at all.
Isak's exit changed the dynamics
Alexander Isak's £125million move to Liverpool in August 2025, which played out over a brutal summer, changed the dynamics of the squad at Newcastle. It also shone a light on what could be achieved with the right amount of chiselling away at a board that lacked leadership.
While CEO David Hopkinson and sporting director Ross Wilson were in place when Anthony Gordon was sold to Barcelona for £69m and Sandro Tonali went to Tottenham Hotspur for £100m, the wheels for any player to "do an Isak" were already in motion. It was not the wish of Newcastle's top brass for Bruno to leave this summer.
A messy break-up
The World Cup was always going to be a big window for Bruno to impress, and while he didn't have a great tournament by his standards, by then Tonali and Gordon had got big money moves. At 29, this was his time and his agents were instructed accordingly before Arsenal eventually paid £75million for his services.
Did Bruno go through the front door in the end like he wanted? Probably not, the break-up was messy and for some fans they will never forgive him. The Carabao Cup-winning captain's mind was all but made up after not qualifying for Europe at all.
Reception on return
Walking back through the doors at the Milburn Stand will be tough for him before any boos or jeers are factored in. The volume of disgust directed at Andy Cole when he returned to Toon as a Manchester United player following his 1995 switch from Kevin Keegan's Newcastle is remembered, but Cole was eventually given a standing ovation at a dinner at St James' Park when he was inducted into the club's hall of fame.
Cole, choked up, told me: "I can't come to Newcastle and feel down after something like that (picking up the award). This is what your career should be about. Looking back and reminiscing. And you know what I'm not very good at looking back. But as I have got older, and especially with what I've gone through, you can look back."
Footballers are human beings at the end of the day, and Bruno's reasons for leaving may be accepted by some fans. The feeling will probably be one of negativity towards Bruno, and he will likely get booed. That will probably upset a player that was often close to tears during Newcastle's most emotional moments between 2022 and 2026. He cried after defeats and he cried when Newcastle won the cup.
While he may be in for a hot reception, in the fullness of time he will get the appreciation that will be due to him, maybe at the end of his career, maybe sooner. Isak scored what proved to be the winner in the cup final but his relationship may be beyond repair. Bruno's case feels different, but emotions are too raw for any sentiment to soften the break-up just yet.