Jarrad Branthwaite was left out of Thomas Tuchel's England squad for the 3-2 victory over Spain at the Riyadh Air Metropolitano Stadium, with the Everton defender's suitability to the national team's style of play called into question.
Branthwaite was not alone in missing out on a place in the 23-man matchday squad, with Everton team-mates James Garner and Josh King also left out. Garner had at least come off the bench during the previous win over Croatia at Wembley, only for VAR to rule out what he thought was his first England goal for offside.
Tuchel's concerns over Branthwaite
All Branthwaite endured during his time with the Three Lions was Tuchel revealing concerns over his suitability to England's way of playing. "Jarrad Branthwaite is doing very well but it's a very different style of play for him from Everton towards us," the German said ahead of the game against Croatia.
Alarm bells started ringing when Tuchel selected Dan Burn over the Everton star for the 2-1 win at Wembley, claiming: "You can see that Dan Burn is straight away a big voice in training and is more used to the style with Newcastle from the last two seasons with Eddie Howe, where they followed in a high press and man-to-man."
That is not because Newcastle United defender Burn is not a good defender, but more because he was not even included in Tuchel's original squad. Tuchel's explanation might explain why Burn is more immediately comfortable with certain tactical demands, but familiarity should not automatically trump ability.
Everton fans know Branthwaite's worth
International football should not become a reward system for players whose club managers happen to use similar tactics. Branthwaite deserves more than being messed around and more than being told he needs time to understand the England way.
Everton supporters have watched him perform under pressure in the Premier League for a good couple of years now. They have watched him make difficult defending look remarkably straightforward and have watched him take responsibility and demonstrate a maturity beyond his years. Nobody is suggesting that he is the finished article, as there is certainly room for improvement.
But there is a difference between acknowledging that a young defender has room to improve and overlooking the extraordinary potential already sitting in front of you. Tuchel seems more interested in what Branthwaite cannot immediately offer within his preferred system than what he could bring to the team.
Time for a proper opportunity
David Moyes will be happy to have him rested and avoid injury during this break, and the same can be said for Garner. With Everton not back in action until Monday, they now have more than a full week of rest before no doubt starting at Brentford.
Branthwaite has made two substitute appearances under the German, totalling 28 minutes. There should be absolutely no talk about Branthwaite needing to move to a so-called bigger club or spend a season playing European football before his ability is properly appreciated; his performances for the Blues should be enough.
Thomas Tuchel may eventually come around and give Branthwaite a proper opportunity, so he can discover what Evertonians have been watching for years. Everton supporters know exactly how good Jarrad Branthwaite is; perhaps it is time Tuchel and England caught up.