Liverpool's decision to appoint Arne Slot over Ruben Amorim has been vindicated as the two managers experience vastly contrasting fortunes in the Premier League. After Jurgen Klopp announced his departure in January 2024, Liverpool considered Amorim but ultimately chose Slot, while Manchester United hired Amorim in November 2024 after sacking Erik ten Hag.
Reports indicate Liverpool had several reservations about Amorim. His preferred 3-4-3 system was deemed tactically inflexible and unsuitable for the squad Klopp left behind, which was used to a flat back four in a 4-3-3. The nearly £10million buy-out clause for Amorim also deterred Liverpool, along with tensions over premature reporting of their interest. Slot, by contrast, favoured a 4-2-4 system that aligned with Liverpool's existing personnel.
Since joining United, Amorim has struggled. The Red Devils were eliminated from the Carabao Cup in the second round by League Two side Grimsby Town. United finished 15th in the Premier League last season and lost the Europa League final to Tottenham Hotspur in May. Amorim's win rate at United stands at just 35.6%, compared to 71% at Sporting CP, and he has won only 16 of 45 matches in charge.
Despite significant spending, including £29m for Patrick Dorgu, £62.5m for Matheus Cunha, £71m for Bryan Mbeumo, and £74m for Benjamin Sesko, United's form has not improved. Meanwhile, Slot led Liverpool to the Premier League title in his first season and is fast becoming an Anfield icon. The contrasting trajectories underscore Liverpool's wisdom in rejecting Amorim.
