A new survey has revealed that football supporters remain deeply sceptical of video assistant referees (VAR), with an overwhelming 91% believing the sport is better off without the controversial technology. The annual poll by the Football Supporters' Association, which involved more than 7,000 fans, most of whom attend matches regularly, highlights widespread dissatisfaction more than eight years after VAR's initial trials in English football.
Fans Voice Strong Disapproval of VAR
In the survey, only 2% of respondents agreed that VAR "makes football more enjoyable," while a mere 3% said it improved the matchday experience. Conversely, 91% disagreed with these positive statements, and 81% expressed a preference for watching games without video technology. This data underscores a significant disconnect between fan sentiment and the ongoing implementation of VAR in competitions.
Specific Criticisms and Limited Support
Fans cited several key issues with VAR, with 96% disagreeing that decisions are "generally resolved in a reasonable amount of time," pointing to delays as a major frustration. Additionally, 92% agreed that "VAR has removed the spontaneous joy of goal celebrations," highlighting its impact on the emotional aspect of the game. Despite these criticisms, there was some support for specific uses: 56% backed VAR for determining offsides in goal buildups, and over 60% thought it should check for possible fouls.
New VAR Extensions Face Resistance
While more than half of fans approved of in-stadium communication from referees to explain VAR decisions in the Premier League this season, other proposed extensions were met with disapproval. Only 21% agreed that VAR should adjudicate on corner kick awards, a system set for trial at the upcoming World Cup. A majority also opposed plans to use VAR for checking second yellow card decisions, indicating scepticism towards expanding its role.
Future of VAR Under Review
Whether fan opinions will influence football's decision-makers remains uncertain. Competition organisers and major clubs remain committed to VAR, and the International Football Association Board (Ifab) has announced a two-year review into its performance. However, there is no suggestion of abandoning the technology altogether. Mark Bullingham, chief executive of the Football Association, described the review as focusing on "how we use VAR to our best and that balance between getting the big decisions right and not slowing the game down."
The survey results paint a clear picture of fan disillusionment, with VAR continuing to be a polarising topic in football. As debates over its efficacy and impact persist, the sport's authorities face mounting pressure to address concerns while maintaining the integrity of the game.
