Smith's silence reshapes sandpapergate legacy as captaincy looms
Smith silence reshapes sandpapergate legacy

Steve Smith's silence during the resurgent sandpapergate debate is speaking louder than words, reshaping his legacy and potentially positioning him to reclaim the Australian Test captaincy eight years after the scandal cost him the role.

Australian cricket is again consumed by discussion of the 2018 ball tampering incident in Cape Town, reignited by Usman Khawaja's autobiography, David Warner's commentary, Pat Cummins' 68-minute press conference and Cameron Bancroft's 4,000-word first-person account. Yet Smith, central to the original story, has remained quiet.

Central role in the 2018 scandal

Smith was as central to the saga as anyone when Bancroft was filmed handling sandpaper on the field at Newlands during the third Test against South Africa in 2018. His insistence on fronting the media in the aftermath, which Bancroft said was done with an expectation that "owning up to the incident would help contain the damage and allow us to move forward", ensured his place as one of the drama's main characters.

Images of a shell-shocked Smith's walk of shame at Johannesburg airport days later, then of him breaking down in tears as he spoke to media after landing in Sydney, are among the most enduring from the time. The then-Australian captain, like Bancroft and vice-captain Warner, paid a price now widely considered disproportionate: a 12-month suspension and a two-year leadership ban, with the stigma since attached to Smith for his role in the saga.

Staying out of the crossfire

While several teammates and coaches from that tour have picked sides and taken aim at each other, Smith has stayed out of the crossfire. Keeping his own counsel since returning from the playing ban, and especially in recent weeks, has inadvertently painted him in a more positive light, potentially the biggest step he has taken in earning back respect and public sympathy since being banned by Cricket Australia in 2018 for his failure of leadership.

Bancroft's essay published this week turned the blowtorch on Cummins with an emotional account of feeling "angry, betrayed and alone" while watching the current captain deny any knowledge of the ball tampering plot. His account reinforced another image that has followed Smith: a batter so absorbed in his technique that he has treated everything away from the crease as a distraction.

Single-mindedness and the path back

Bancroft said when the sandpaper plan was floated in Port Elizabeth, Smith entered the conversation and made clear "he wanted no part in it before distancing himself". When sandpaper was having the desired effect during the second Test, Smith dodged the discussion with the line: "I don't want to know about it."

An ability to block outside noise is part of what has made Smith one of Australia's batting greats with more than 11,000 runs and 37 centuries across 127 Tests. "Steve just wanted to clear it so he could focus on batting," Bancroft recalled as to why his captain wanted to press ahead with a media conference when advised to wait.

This same mentality was part of his downfall in 2018, but now it could be the key to him going full circle in the twilight of his career. The 37-year-old is fairly presumed to be in the early days of his farewell tour, with high-stakes Test series in India and England following a home summer against New Zealand.

As pressure mounts on Cummins over whether he can hold on to the captaincy while senior bowlers stand firm on their position that they were not aware of the sandpaper plot, Smith remains off to the side, batting in the shadows. He has maintained his silence even after returning from New York to prepare for the summer's four Tests with a Sheffield Shield hit-out with New South Wales this weekend.

The silence will have to come to an end soon, but the longer Smith keeps his own counsel, the more it feels like his sandpapergate legacy is being reshaped to put the player who just wants to bat back in the frame to reclaim the reins of the Test team.