The Work and Pensions Secretary has confirmed that certain young people will no longer receive benefits they are presently entitled to, ahead of the publication of a major review designed to address the increase in youth unemployment.
Minister Pat McFadden stated that a "complete reset" of the system was required to support 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training, whose numbers exceeded one million earlier this year. Amidst concerns from some backbenchers regarding the scope of future support, he encouraged MPs to view the changes as a "different proposition" to last year, when the Government scrapped planned welfare cuts following a rebellion.
Milburn Review Set for Tuesday
This comes before the release of Alan Milburn's review of so-called Neets - under-25s not in employment, education or training - on Tuesday, which is anticipated to recommend sweeping changes to reduce welfare dependency.
Mr Milburn has indicated that certain young people will receive reduced financial support under his proposals, which include transferring them from some health-related benefits onto a new "youth allowance" paid at the standard rate of universal credit.
When asked whether he agreed that some individuals should lose the welfare they currently receive, the Cabinet minister told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg show: "There will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today."
McFadden Defends Reforms
He refused to confirm whether the overall working-age benefits bill would be reduced by the next election, stating: "Look, I can't say that – we uprate benefits every year, and I think it's important to keep people up with the cost of living. These are some of the poorest people in the country, and the best way to get the benefits bill down is with the long-term reset that we are talking about."
Andy Burnham has described the politically sensitive report as a "watershed" moment, yet stopped short of pledging to accept its recommendations in their entirety or provide a "blanket assurance." The Prime Minister also maintained that funding the reforms would not require "more money" but "spending differently" within Government, when pressed on the considerable upfront investment they are anticipated to demand.
Amid concerns over whether the Government would be able to secure the support of its MPs for any changes it adopts, Mr McFadden argued that ministers must pursue reforms not "in spite of being Labour people", but "because we're Labour people".
"If you're 20 right now and you sign on to long-term sickness benefits, you've got more chance of marking your 30th birthday and still being on them than having a steady job in between," he said. "And the reason we have to change that isn't in spite of being Labour people, it's because we are Labour people."
He told Sky News' Sunday Morning show: "It's a different proposition from last year, and I hope that Parliament views it in that light. We need a complete reset of the system in terms of what it offers young people to get these numbers," he said.
Milburn's 10-Year Plan
Mr Milburn said it would take 10 years to reach a "reasonable level" of Neets, arguing that moving more quickly or aggressively would simply result in "crude cuts" that see young people appearing elsewhere in the Government's accounts. He said investment would likely run into the "billions" over this period, adding: "But what you get back is you get welfare savings back, and then you get the so-called fiscal benefits of young people not being reliant on a benefit but being paid a wage."
The former Labour health secretary, who was commissioned by Sir Keir Starmer's government to conduct the review after it was compelled to dilute its own welfare plans in the face of a backbench rebellion, also said young people deserve a "legal guarantee" of a pathway into employment.
The proposal was supported by the Work and Pensions Secretary, who on Sunday said employment support required a "legislative underpinning" with people given "more certainty about what they're entitled to."
When asked whether this would result in young people having the right to take legal action if no opportunities were available to them, Mr Milburn told the BBC: "We're going to avoid that elephant trap, believe me. But we are going to have a duty on Government to provide opportunities. We're calling it the opportunity guarantee, so there should be a guarantee for a young person because at the moment the only guarantee they've got is to a very simple thing, to get a benefit."
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately argued that establishing a legal entitlement "might sound a nice thing to do" but "doesn't make sense".
Yet the Conservative frontbencher cautiously endorsed other aspects of Mr Milburn's proposals, suggesting his emphasis on moving away from "handing out cash for relatively mild conditions" and towards employment support was "the right direction of travel".
"We think he should do it for all ages, not just under 25. You should not have a different system for a 24-year-old and a 26-year-old," she told Sky.
Reform UK's Danny Kruger likewise stated he was "encouraged" by "the suggestion that we need to be much stricter about benefits for young people who should be supported into work or should be working".
However, he expressed doubt that Labour would embrace this, telling the same programme: "There'll be indications that they want to, but the fact is, as we saw with Keir Starmer's rather weak attempt to make a couple of billion pounds of savings from the welfare bill last year, the backbenchers won't take it."
The MP further remarked: "I expect Labour will end up taking the extra spending on support for young people, but they won't do the cuts. What we actually need to do is to take a much more robust approach."