Andy Burnham is facing backbench rebellions over the benefits bill and North Sea oil approvals, the same pressures that destroyed Keir Starmer's premiership, according to a political analysis.
Labour MPs originally backed Burnham as their best chance of saving their seats at the next election, but he now appears to be repeating Starmer's mistakes, including dithering and U-turns. Within months, Burnham has become a prisoner of the same backbenchers who cheered Starmer into Number 10 and then began pushing him around.
Benefits rebellion repeats
Two rebellions are being cooked up, one on the same issue that damaged Starmer: the benefits bill. In her first Budget, Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced flagship reforms to reduce the benefits bill by £6 billion, which amounted to less than 2% of the annual total. More than 120 Labour MPs threatened to vote down her plans, forcing a last-minute U-turn that destroyed Starmer's authority.
Reeves saved nothing, crushing her fiscal plans. Starmer's premiership sank, and backbenchers tore chunks off his political corpse. Burnham watched from Manchester, and now it is his turn to be bait as the same predators line up.
Oil field approvals targeted
Backbench rebels are gathering signatures to target Burnham. He defied the Left by approving the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea, which is not controversial given Britain has 26 million gas boilers and is in the middle of an energy crisis. Now Burnham is delaying a decision on the Rosebank oil field off Shetland. Backbenchers are collecting signatures for a letter, already holding 75 names and expecting more than 100, roughly one in four Labour MPs.
The letter is deliberately modelled on the benefits rebellion, which taught MPs the power they collectively wield. The Cabinet is split, with Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband lobbying against Rosebank while Chancellor John Healey is desperate to get it done.
Neets plan faces opposition
This may not be Burnham's biggest rebellion. Former Labour Cabinet minister Alan Milburn is setting out a plan to tackle the surge in young people not in education, employment or training, known as Neets. Milburn is not actually doing anything to cut the cost of benefits, knowing MPs will kill that. Instead, he wants to spend even more by subsidising wages and funding mental health and training programmes to get young people into work. He admits it won't save a penny over 10 years. Even that is too much for the rebels, who are rejecting "crude austerity cuts" even though there aren't any.
Burnham is discovering what Starmer learned the hard way: Labour won too many seats at the last election, leaving an army of posturing backbenchers who have nothing better to do than cause trouble. Now Burnham faces the same grisly fate.