Senior DWP Official Blames Carers for Benefits Scandal
Senior DWP Official Blames Carers for Benefits Scandal

A senior civil servant at the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has blamed carers for the carer's allowance overpayment scandal, contradicting an independent review that found systemic failures by the department. Neil Couling, director general of DWP services, wrote in an internal blogpost that individual failings by carers were 'at the heart' of the issue, which has left many with life-changing debts. The post was removed after the Guardian made inquiries.

The independent review, led by disability rights expert Liz Sayce, concluded last month that longstanding and 'unacceptable' DWP leadership problems and poor benefit design were the root cause. It stated that carers could not be blamed, and some had contemplated suicide due to shame and distress. The review found that senior DWP leaders had failed to address problems for a decade despite warnings.

Couling's blogpost acknowledged that the DWP's 'byzantine' guidance on averaging earnings contributed to overpayments, but he argued that the core issue was carers not reporting changes in circumstances. This contrasts with the government's own position, which accepts that the DWP's confusing guidance and unclear processes were the main cause.

Charities and politicians have condemned Couling's remarks. Kirsty McHugh of Carers Trust called it a 'serious error of judgment', while Liberal Democrat leader Sir Ed Davey expressed disgust, saying senior DWP officials had 'learned nothing'. Emily Holzhausen of Carers UK stated that blaming claimants 'misses the point entirely'.

The government has announced it will reassess overpayments from the past decade, with about 200,000 cases to be reviewed. DWP permanent secretary Sir Peter Schofield apologised to MPs, calling the situation a 'mess' inherited from the previous government. Between 2019 and 2025, 180,000 carers accrued £300m in debts, and 854 were convicted of fraud.