UK government not ready for disasters, peers warn
UK government not ready for disasters, peers warn

The public has been stocking up on bottled water, tinned food and wind-up radios since the government launched its Be Ready campaign last month. But the missing element is not public willingness to prepare, according to Jean Coussins, chair of the House of Lords national resilience committee. She argues the government fails to provide candid information about the escalating nature and frequency of threats, and lacks a coherent resilience plan that can be activated from the top of government down to local, community and household levels.

Government admits it does not want to frighten people

In July, the then security minister, Angela Eagle, admitted to the House of Lords national resilience committee that the government did not want to “frighten people”. Coussins warns that shielding the public from uncomfortable realities risks leaving them ill prepared for emergencies they need to withstand.

She calls for a cabinet minister responsible solely for resilience, as in Denmark and Sweden, where dedicated ministers oversee resilience and civil defence. This would establish clear responsibility and accountability at the highest level of government.

Vulnerable people and supply chains at risk

Coussins notes that central government may advise people to stock up on food, water and cash, but for a single mum on benefits living on the 10th floor of a tower block where the lift does not work, this looks like wishful thinking. She urges national and local registers of volunteers and civil reservists, and easier data-sharing between public bodies, to identify and support vulnerable people in an emergency. Systems should be built and tested far ahead of a crisis, not cobbled together in recovery mode. She also calls for scrapping proposals to switch off digital terrestrial TV, which would weaken access to crucial information when needed most.

The UK is acutely vulnerable due to supply-chain dependencies for critical products such as food, medicines and fertiliser. About 95% of food sold in the UK is controlled by 12 retailers, while the country remains heavily dependent on overseas supplies of antibiotics and other medicines. Coussins says the government must invest in rebuilding domestic capacity, especially for life-saving medicines, to reduce the risk of critical shortages during a crisis.

Hybrid threats and the need for honest communication

During the committee’s inquiry, evidence was heard about escalating “grey zone” hostility against the UK from Russia, China and Iran, including cyber-attacks, proxy acts of violence and sabotage of undersea cables on which communications and energy depend. There have been 90,000 cyber-attacks on UK defence networks in a single year, and they are estimated to cost UK businesses £14.7bn a year.

Governments across Europe are contending with these hybrid threats. Experience from Sweden and Finland shows the value of honest communication to the public about such dangers. When Sweden distributed the latest update of its crisis and war preparedness booklet to households in 2024, 82% of those surveyed welcomed the initiative and 63% planned to strengthen their own preparedness. Not being straight with the public risks cynicism, suspicion and people drifting towards unreliable sources.

As well as giving local, voluntary, community and faith organisations a formal role in resilience planning, backed by sustainable funding, the private sector must also be embedded. About 80% of critical national infrastructure is privately owned, yet businesses are too often sidelined in government resilience planning. Providers of essential goods and services should be required to regularly stress-test their facilities, operations and supply chains against major disruptions.

Preparedness should become an everyday, common-sense mindset. Practical resilience skills, from first aid and emergency decision-making to coping with power cuts, water shortages and communications failures, should be taught alongside critical thinking and information literacy at school. The government must use a variety of communication channels, including public broadcasters and social media. Ministers are right to say that the whole of society needs to “be ready”, but so does the whole of government.