Staggered age of consent: UK considers law change after Brand case
UK considers staggered age of consent after Brand case

The UK government is considering changes to the age of consent law following the conviction of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault offences, and separate allegations concerning his past relationship with Mia Latter. Campaigners are questioning whether the current law, which sets the age of consent at 16, does enough to protect young people from sexual exploitation and power imbalances.

Current law and calls for reform

Under existing UK law, adults of any age can legally have consensual sex with 16- and 17-year-olds, unless they hold a position of trust, such as a teacher or coach. Campaigners warn that relationships with much older adults can leave teenagers vulnerable, and the issue has been brought into focus by Brand's conviction and separate sexual misconduct allegations against David Walliams.

Mia Latter, now 37, is calling for a change in the law. She alleges she was in a sexually and emotionally abusive relationship with Brand, now 51, when she was 16 and he was 30. Brand maintains the relationship was consensual. Ms Latter says the relationship had a lasting impact on her mental health and education, and that she left school without completing her A-levels. She also claims Brand referred to her as "the child" around his entourage, and says there was a clear power imbalance between them.

Staggered age of consent proposal

One proposal is to introduce a staggered age of consent. Campaign group Close the Consent Gap, founded by child protection social worker Layla Stone, believes setting an age-gap limit will help protect young people from grooming without criminalising relationships between teenagers who are close in age. They propose a maximum age limit of three years, which would make it illegal for a 16 or 17-year-old to have sex with someone more than three years older than them.

Ms Stone said: "The fact that his 16-year-old victim, Mia Latter, has alleged rape by Brand at that time but is unable to get justice for that, or even seek a criminal trial, is shocking to us." She said Ms Latter "should be protected by the law just for the very fact that she was 16" while Brand was 30, adding: "she shouldn't have to prove anything beyond that". Ms Stone added: "The vulnerability that that power dynamic created should be enough to say that an illegal act was committed. Under the current law, it wasn't."

Political reaction

The government has said it will consider changing the law, although it has yet to explain what that might involve. Speaking to Sky News, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said: "What we'll definitely do is think about whatever we can do to help people at the wrong end of these abuses of power."

Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said it was right to have a debate about the age of consent in the wake of Brand's crimes. "I think if there's one thing we learn from… what has happened, what has unfolded, Russell Brand's terrible crimes, it's we've got to listen to the victims," he told BBC Breakfast. He added that a change in the law "would be a very big step", but said it was right to give space for the debate, listening to victims and victims' rights advocates.

Shadow education secretary Laura Trott said she is glad there is a conversation around staggering the age of consent but warned such a change could be hard to implement. She told Sky News a staggered age of consent, used in some American states, has "been quite complicated to actually implement", and said it has "resulted in some legal judgments that I think many of us would not be happy with in terms of young boys being prosecuted for consensual relationships". She added: "A 16-year-old and a 40-year-old is gross, and I think that everybody should just accept that and acknowledge that. Whether that therefore should be illegal is a different question."

Examples of staggered age of consent

Several countries have a staggered age of consent. In the United States, most states set an unrestricted age of consent between 16 and 18, but some have a staggered approach. In Florida, the general age of consent is 18, but 16 and 17-year-olds can legally consent to partners up to the age of 23. In Canada, the general age of consent is 16, but 14 and 15-year-olds can consent to a partner that is less than five years older, while 12 and 13-year-olds can consent to partners less than two years older.

In Australia, the baseline age of consent is 16 in most states (and 17 in South Australia and Tasmania), with several jurisdictions permitting consensual relationships between young people under the baseline age if they are within a specified age range of one another. In France, the general age of consent is 15, but tougher restrictions introduced in 2021 made having sex with someone under the consenting age liable for a rape conviction, with a Romeo and Juliet clause allowing minors to engage in consensual sexual activity with a partner up to five years older. In Italy, the baseline age of consent is 14, but 13-year-olds can consent with a partner no more than three years older, and the age of consent is 16 if the older partner has a position of authority or influence.

The government has yet to make any firm decisions on what the age ranges should be.