The Government has "one last chance" to get local government reorganisation right, a senior sector figure is set to warn, as trust in the process is on the verge of "completely evaporating".
Sean Williams, chairman of the County Councils Network (CCN), will use his inaugural address to the body's annual conference to warn ministers that the review of proposals to establish unitary councils across two-tier areas is more concerned with bolstering the Government's position than reaching decisions consistent with national objectives.
The process has proved deeply divisive in certain areas, with at least eight councils either launching or considering legal challenges to the Government's chosen footprints for new authorities.
Review of Decisions
In October, Communities Secretary Angela Rayner withdrew decisions on plans across Derbyshire, Devon, Hertfordshire, Kent, Lancashire, Leicestershire, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire and Staffordshire. Decisions taken by her predecessor, Steve Reed, on areas across Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk are also now under review after being withdrawn in September. The case of Cambridge and Peterborough, where a decision had yet to be reached, is also under consideration.
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has stated that the review is intended to ensure the process is robust and consistent with the Government's ambition to "rewire the state", and follows "updated and privileged legal advice".
Call for Evidence-Based Decisions
Mr Williams, who serves as the Reform UK leader of Lincolnshire County Council, will address the CCN's annual conference in Buckinghamshire on Monday, stating he welcomes the review but will challenge the Government's methodology.
He will say: "The Government are right to withdraw previous decisions and look again. But as we stand today, the recent announcement provided little reassurance that the process will be robust, fair and transparent. Indeed, there is growing concern that this review is less about reaching better decisions in line with the original objectives of reorganisation and more about strengthening the Government's legal position, ending previous challenges, and avoiding the full disclosure of previous ministerial advice. Whether or not this is the Government's intention, the perception is very real and potentially very damaging. Trust in the Government's handling of reorganisation has already been severely damaged and for many it is on the verge of completely evaporating."
Urging the Government to prove it is not attempting to safeguard its own position, Mr Williams will press ministers to "genuinely" reassess decisions "that went against the criteria and pose a significant financial, implementation and service risk". "The Government has one last chance to get it right," he will say, insisting decisions must be "based on evidence rather than political or legal expediency".
Devolution and Local Government
Turning to devolution, Mr Williams will argue that councils must remain "at the heart" of reforms. He will say: "If we are serious about rewiring the state, we must get the relationships between central government, local government and our communities right. Devolution cannot simply mean moving power from Westminster to mayors. It must mean empowering and not diminishing the role of local government."
When pressed by the Commons Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee on Wednesday, Ms Rayner defended her stance on reorganisation. She said: "The reason I took the pause was because when I make decisions, I want to know I am making the right decisions and that means I have got to have the information. LGR (local government reorganisation) was always going to be contentious and it was always going to be litigated, let's be honest."
The Communities Secretary stated that the principle of councils working together on proposals and the Government establishing criteria to deliver reorganisation "is the right thing to do". Responding to criticisms of Mr Reed's approach, she added: "I think my predecessor did a really good job actually, but I wasn't involved in the process that he took. I was making sure that I made a fresh decision and that is what I would distinguish, not that it is not a defence of my predecessor."