Milburn urges NI cuts for firms hiring young workers
Milburn urges NI cuts for firms hiring young workers

Former Health Secretary Alan Milburn has proposed targeted reductions in employer National Insurance contributions to tackle the crisis of young people not in employment, education or training (Neets), saying the move would help reverse some of the damage from Rachel Reeves' tax rises.

Call for lower hiring costs

In his proposals, Mr Milburn said some tax reforms were needed to cut the number of Neets. He said he understood why Ms Reeves raised National Insurance in the autumn of 2024, given the economic inheritance from the Tories, but her decision had had "consequences," with bosses telling him how it had hit hiring.

He called for "targeted and phased" cuts to National Insurance for employers. "There should be a glide path to lower National Insurance contributions for those sectors like retail and hospitality that employ so many young people. One in three," he told Times Radio.

Impact on London businesses

London business chiefs had warned Mr Milburn that his proposals would fail unless he cut the cost of hiring. Pubs, clubs, bars and shops were hard hit by the National Insurance increase in the 2024 Budget, which raised employer contributions by some £20 billion and has been widely blamed for thousands of job cuts.

If the Government adopts Mr Milburn's recommendation, it would be a significant boost to many hospitality and retail firms in London, which were heavily impacted by the National Insurance rise and the jump in the Minimum Wage rate for workers aged 18 to 20. London has the highest unemployment in the country.

Reforms to cut Neet rate

In his 267-page landmark reforms, Mr Milburn set out measures to lower the Neet rate by more than half from 13.4% to around 6.8% by 2036, bringing the UK into line with other comparable European countries. The UK rate has never been lower than 9.7% since data began in 2001.

Mr Milburn said Britain should aim to go further and set a new national ambition for a 5% Neet rate, which he dubbed "Neet Zero". He proposed a variety of reforms to the welfare system and new support for young people, including:

  • Giving up to £7,000 to employers for hiring under-25s who have been a Neet for six months, while also expecting them to create more youth jobs.
  • Lowering employer National Insurance contributions over a five-year period for workers aged 21 to 24, initially targeting hospitality and retail businesses.
  • A greater focus on technical and vocational education, including doubling the number of apprenticeships by 2036.
  • A new youth opportunity service rolled out across all of England by 2029, aiming to be young people's single point of contact on employment, careers, health and practical support.

Reaction and criticism

The report's recommendation that young people's entitlement to the main sickness and disability benefits be replaced with a new "youth allowance" has drawn criticism from charities. Katie Schmuecker, principal policy adviser at the Joseph Roundtree Foundation, said "cutting sick and disabled young people's benefits should not be part of this package".

Welfare savings would begin in 2029, Mr Milburn said, and could result in an accumulated £13.7 billion welfare savings in a decade's time, as well as adding 0.4% GDP to economic growth per year by 2036.

Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Helen Whately said: "Where Milburn gets it right, we'll back him. Especially where he adopts our proposals like shifting from cash sickness benefits to support for milder conditions and cutting national insurance for young people."