The House of Lords National Resilience Committee has recommended the Government abandon its plan to switch off Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT), warning that the move would weaken national resilience and reduce universal access to communication.
The recommendation follows an investigation into the UK's preparedness for crisis, which highlighted concerns over vulnerable communities in the event of major issues hitting the country. Recent events cited include cyber attacks on supermarket fridges, Microsoft services being cut off, snow, and a summer heatwave.
Concerns Over Vulnerable Communities
The committee's report stated: "Witnesses also raised concerns about maintaining universal access to Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT). Broadcast2040+ warned that the Government's intention to reduce or end DTT from the mid-2030s would require households to receive television through broadband." The report added that this would "weaken national resilience by reducing universal access", including among vulnerable people.
The Government's Green Paper, released in July, proposed scrapping aerial-based DTT in favour of internet-based services, with the earliest proposed transition date set for 2034. This would end Freeview, which currently serves 12.9 million homes and remains the primary television platform for 40 per cent of households with a set. Experts have warned people could be forced to pay an extra £20 a month and even get a new television set.
Emergency Communications Concerns
The committee was told that measures are currently in place to maintain communications with the public during emergencies. The Cabinet Office said its Emergency Alerts system is capable of distributing life-saving information quickly and is maintained through regular testing. Roger Hargreaves told the committee that the Government has "the arrangements with broadcasters to put out emergency broadcasts when power is absent".
The committee's recommendations concluded: "Older technologies also remain important where digital communications fail, making the Government's dependence on digital systems without comprehensive back-up arrangements a significant resilience weakness. We recommend that the Government should abandon its plan to switch off Digital Terrestrial Television, which risks weakening national resilience by reducing universal access to communication, as well as learn lessons from the switching off of the Public Switched Telephone Network on 31 January 2027."
Campaign to Preserve Freeview
A spokesperson for campaign group Broadcast 2040+ said: "We welcome this clear recommendation from the committee, which further highlights the importance of protecting terrestrial television. At a time of growing threats, switching it off would be a mistake we cannot fix. Ministers should take this recommendation seriously and commit to a long-term future for terrestrial TV until at least 2044."
Broadcasters contend that maintaining dual transmission systems is becoming increasingly costly, and switching off Freeview would save millions in distribution costs. However, a substantial campaign has emerged to preserve the service, arguing it will disproportionately impact elderly people, vulnerable individuals and those in rural communities.
Jonathan Thompson, Chief Executive Officer of Everyone TV, said: "Free TV isn't going anywhere. This is a debate about the long-term future of television distribution, and any transition to internet-delivered TV would need to be carefully managed to ensure nobody is left behind. The latest BARB data shows that 2.6 million households currently rely on terrestrial television because they don't have broadband or an internet-connected TV. 870,000 Freeview homes have no broadband at all. The scale of the households affected by any future transition will be significantly smaller than the figures being suggested in the wider debate."
Government figures released in July revealed that 70 per cent of rural residences have access to gigabit-capable broadband, compared to 92 per cent in towns and cities. In the most remote rural locations, this figure dropped to just 60 per cent.
Silver Voices Director Dennis Reed cautioned that switching off Freeview could become 'Burnham's winter fuel moment'. "Andy Burnham would be bonkers to proceed with this premature plan. Most affected would be low income families and pensioners who will not be able to afford the [broadband] contracts, and those in isolated and rural communities who cannot receive fast broadband at all. Mark my words, if the Freeview switch off goes ahead it will become Burnham's winter fuel moment."