Burnham urges Google to remove Russell Brand video but rejects law change
Burnham urges Google to remove Brand video, rejects law change

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has urged Google to remove a YouTube video in which Russell Brand protests his innocence through his wife Laura Gallacher, telling social media companies they should “show some responsibility”. Speaking in Berlin, he said he “wouldn't leap” to changing legislation to compel platforms to take down such content.

Video stays online despite ministerial request

The video, in which Ms Gallacher read out a message from Brand maintaining he is not guilty, has remained on YouTube several days after ministers requested its removal. Ms Gallacher delivered the message on their YouTube podcast on Sunday, prompting an official investigation into whether Brand had breached prison rules.

Brand is currently serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence after being found guilty of one count of rape and three sexual assaults at Southwark Crown Court on November 5.

Government lacks legal power to force removal

The Government does not have the authority to compel YouTube's parent company Google to take down the video, but has been in “dialogue” with the tech giant over the matter. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook earlier told broadcasters that the Government has no legal power to force removal. Justice officials lodged a formal request with Google seeking the removal of the footage, but reports emerged overnight that Google rejected the request after determining its guidelines had not been violated.

Asked about the stand-off, a Downing Street spokeswoman said: “We trust that they will do the right thing.”

Focus on victims, Burnham says

Speaking in Berlin, Mr Burnham said: “I feel for the victims. We've heard quite enough from this convicted criminal. It's time that we focus on the victims and think about them. And I would call on those social media companies to take these interviews down. You know, why are we having to hear from from him? We shouldn't be, and certainly (the victims) shouldn't be hearing from him.”

He added that the focus should be on issues raised by victims, including the security of women and girls in everyday life, power imbalances in the media industry, politics and elsewhere, and the conduct of rape trials, rather than “hearing from, as I say, a convicted criminal”.

Political reactions and platform actions

Meta suspended Brand's Instagram and Facebook accounts following his conviction. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch indicated that, were she in power, she would not immediately move to demand Google pull the video. She told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: “My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. The rule of law applies to everyone in this country. His wife is a separate person. She can make the protestations that she likes.”