Piccadilly Gardens is one of the most debated public spaces in Manchester, with a reputation for anti-social behaviour that has been amplified by social media. However, a visit by the Manchester Evening News found a more nuanced reality, with many people feeling safe and enjoying the area, while authorities push forward with plans for a major transformation.
Concerns and criticism
The area has faced intense scrutiny, especially as political attention has focused on Manchester. Recent viral videos have shown fights, rats, and alleged drug use, leading to the nickname 'Crackadilly'. High-profile commentators like Jeremy Kyle and Katie Hopkins have criticised the state of the gardens, linking it to former mayor Andy Burnham.
Manchester council acknowledges the issues. Coun Garry Bridges, interim leader, said: "No one is going to argue that Piccadilly Gardens is good enough at the moment. We know there are issues in the area. That's why we are bringing forward plans to make big changes for the better." He also noted that social media can create a "distorted and exaggerated picture" of the area.
A different perspective
During a day spent in Piccadilly Gardens, the M.E.N. observed office workers eating lunch, families using the play area, and people relaxing on the grass. Many visitors expressed positive views. Rachel Egan, 20, from Gorton, said: "I love Piccadilly Gardens. Obviously, over the years, it's not the same anymore, but it's still a good environment... I feel very safe."
Rhiannon Martin, 20, from Wigan, added: "I really like Piccadilly Gardens. There aren't a lot of spaces around Manchester that are so open and grassy... it's just a cute little square." Len Ingram, 59, visiting from Leicester, said: "I've not seen or experienced any potential trouble so I feel safe. The rumours probably aren't true in the daytime."
Night-time concerns
Despite the positive daytime experiences, some expressed concerns about the evenings. Neelam Kaur, 39, from Altrincham, said she would leave by 4 or 5pm, especially with children, as "it can get a little bit rough." Ella Coffie, 22, from Droylsden, described the area as "overwhelming" at night, adding: "I don't think it's really safe at night, but during the day it's fine."
During a Wednesday night visit, the M.E.N. observed a busy area with many young people, but no major incidents. Some street drinkers and cannabis smokers were present, but most people passed through without trouble. An ambulance attended a medical incident, but there was no criminal involvement.
Police response and future plans
Greater Manchester Police say Piccadilly Gardens is a focus for resources. Chief Inspector Mike Tachauer said: "One of the areas where we focus a number of our resources is Piccadilly Gardens - whether that is utilising our Live Facial Recognition vans and our mounted unit during the day, to our proactive uniformed and undercover patrols at night." He added: "We remain committed to improving both the perception of Piccadilly Gardens and the public's sense of safety in the area."
New mayor Bev Craig has visited the area and called for more police, better CCTV, and improved lighting. Manchester council has released plans for a transformation, including more green space, a new event space, and a larger play area. Coun Bridges said: "There are real issues here which we're determined to address to create a Piccadilly Gardens which is safer and more attractive." The planning application is expected next week.
