Girlguiding has defended its policy allowing transgender individuals to join, rejecting claims that it puts girls at risk. The organisation stated that 'simply being transgender does not make someone more of a safeguarding risk than any other person'.
The policy has faced criticism from some of its 500,000 members, leading to the withdrawal of two leaders' memberships after they publicly objected. Critics argue that the policy poses safeguarding risks, reinforces gender stereotypes, and denies informed parental consent.
In a joint statement, chief guide Amanda Medler and chief executive Ruth Marvel described much of the criticism as 'inaccurate, aggressive and counter to the values we hold dear'. They emphasised that their focus remains on providing a safe, inclusive, and legally compliant environment for young members.
The organisation said it developed its policies based on legal advice and the practices of other organisations experienced in supporting transgender young people. It denied being influenced by individuals or pressure groups, noting that the law around transgender issues is 'new and complex' and that policies will be reviewed as needed.
In April, 224 current and former leaders, volunteers, and parents signed an open letter opposing the policy. Among them was Helen Watts, a Rainbows unit leader in Ealing, west London, who was asked to leave after reportedly encouraging others to breach the policy on social media. An independent investigation found both leaders had violated the volunteer code of conduct.
