In a striking intervention that could shape Labour's approach to regional governance, Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham has issued a pointed warning to Sir Keir Starmer about the pitfalls of previous Labour governments' devolution strategies.
The Ghost of Devolution Past
Burnham, speaking with the authority of a senior Labour figure who has served in both Westminster and regional leadership, cautioned Starmer against repeating what he described as Tony Blair's "half-hearted" approach to devolving power from Whitehall.
"The lesson from the Blair years is clear," Burnham emphasised. "Piecemeal devolution that maintains ultimate control in London simply doesn't deliver the transformative change regions like Manchester need."
A Blueprint for Meaningful Change
The Manchester mayor outlined his vision for what genuine devolution should entail:
- Substantial control over transport infrastructure and planning
- Greater autonomy over skills and employment programmes
- Proper revenue-raising powers rather than reliance on Whitehall grants
- Long-term funding settlements to enable strategic planning
Burnham stressed that the current system leaves regional leaders "constantly fighting with one hand tied behind our backs" when trying to address local challenges.
The Political Calculus
This intervention comes at a crucial political moment, with Starmer's Labour enjoying substantial poll leads but facing questions about the substance behind their policy proposals. Burnham's warning serves as both advice and a marker being laid down about what northern Labour heartlands expect from a potential Starmer government.
"People in regions like ours don't want symbolism—they want substance," Burnham declared, making clear that the political price for inadequate devolution could be high in areas that have traditionally been Labour strongholds.
Learning from Experience
Having served as Health Secretary and held other senior cabinet positions under Gordon Brown before moving into regional politics, Burnham brings unique perspective to the devolution debate. His journey from Westminster insider to powerful metro mayor gives his warnings particular resonance within Labour circles.
The Manchester leader's comments suggest he intends to be a significant voice shaping Labour's approach to English governance if the party returns to power, positioning himself as both ally and critical friend to the leadership.
As Starmer finalises his party's manifesto commitments, Burnham's very public counsel serves notice that the devolution settlement will be a key battleground—and potential vulnerability—for Labour in the coming election campaign.
