The aviary at the Botanic Gardens in Churchtown could cost taxpayers more than £1.3m to bring up to basic standards, according to an independent investigation into what is needed for it to safely continue operating.
The report, which looked at what would be required to ensure the aviary can accommodate the needs of all its animals, said the entire site would need to be nearly doubled in size and that this would cost £1.34m.
Council reverses closure plans after legal challenge
Sefton Council, which owns and runs the aviary, had begun plans to close the attraction in early 2026. However, a legal challenge by local campaigners led to a U-turn and the plans being rescinded.
The aviary has been open for 87 years.
Public consultation opens on future of the aviary
A consultation has now opened to ask the public what they think. Taxpayers will be asked if they agree that a managed closure is the most appropriate next step. Those who disagree will be given the option to recommend financially robust and responsible alternatives to be considered.
The consultation runs from Friday, November 20, to Friday, February 19, 2027, lasting 13 weeks. Comments made by the public will then be considered through the council's democratic processes.
Cllr Marion Atkinson, leader of Sefton Council, said: "This independent report is sobering and goes far beyond any of our initial concerns. One scenario is taxpayers will have to pay for these vital repairs and improvements so it is only fair we ask them what they think."
Expansion would nearly double accommodation
She added: "A lot of factors need to be considered including the cost, loss of the surrounding nature any necessary expansion would incur and, as we have always said, the welfare of the animals there currently. Significantly expanded accommodation would be needed. To put that into perspective this would require the current indoor and outdoor accommodation to be nearly doubled in size."
The council leader said: "We recognise the affection many people have for the aviary and the dedication of volunteers who have supported it. However we all agree the welfare of the animals and the long-term suitability of the structure are vital."
She described the concerns as serious ones that the council has to address, adding: "We are consulting but it would be unfair not to present the most transparent picture that we face. Anyone can read the independent report on our website."
Funding and operating costs considered
The report notes that ongoing staffing, veterinary care, maintenance and operating costs are set to exceed £80,000 a year, on top of the £1.3m needed for refurbishment. Any alternative proposal would need to demonstrate that suitable accommodation could be delivered without unacceptable impacts on the wider historically important gardens, and would be subject to planning permission and environmental impact assessments.
Cllr Atkinson said: "We must consider whether that investment, together with ongoing staffing, veterinary care, maintenance and operating costs, which are set to exceed £80,000 a year – on top of the £1.3 million needed for refurbishment, can be justified alongside our statutory responsibilities and demands on public funding."
She added that residents will be able to examine the reasons why measures such as closure are being proposed alongside realistic alternatives, which would need to demonstrate suitable animal accommodation, an acceptable impact on the park and a secure, sustainable funding and operating model.
"We will consider those responses carefully before a final decision following consultation. The welfare of the animals and the responsible use of public money will remain central to that consideration," she said. More information about the consultation can be found on Sefton Council's website.