Lambeth Council has declared a “financial emergency” after saying it will have to write off £68 million of “bad debt” owed by its housing development company, Homes for Lambeth (HfL).
The Green-run town hall said the company, set up by the previous Labour administration in 2017 to build 900 new social and affordable properties, only constructed 120 social rent homes and acquired another 134 from private developers, despite receiving £123 million from the council.
Review and further funding
After concerns about the body’s delivery and value for money were raised, senior civil servant Sir Bob Kerslake published a review in 2022 recommending that HfL be scrapped and its duties brought in house. However, the Green Party said that for the next two years a further £40 million of taxpayer cash was ploughed into the company by the then Labour council, meaning each social property cost around £500,000.
The local authority faces a budget blackhole of £143 million over the next three years. Council leader Martin Abrams has written to Housing Secretary Angela Rayner and the town hall’s auditors calling for emergency funding.
Letter to the Housing Secretary
The letter states that HfL “still owes tens of millions of pounds to the council, debt which we will never recover”. It adds: “Minimally, we expect to write off £68 million. This episode has had a disastrous impact on the financial position of Lambeth Council.
“As we contemplate £53 million of cuts budgeted by the previous Labour administration and a further £93 million of budget gap over the next three years, we must reflect on how far Homes for Lambeth is responsible for this crisis.”
It is understood that Lambeth is one of several London boroughs in discussion with the government about hiking council tax bills above the 5% cap to help balance budgets.
Leader’s response
Mr Abrams said: “Over the past ten years, vast sums of public money have been wasted on a development vehicle that failed to deliver the social housing it promised, and whose finances remain murky.
“The HfL scandal, alongside years of central government cuts, has put Lambeth in a state of financial emergency.
“It is not right that residents pay the price for this scandalous mismanagement, and they have a right to know what has happened with public money.
“This government promised an end to austerity. I urge Angela Rayner to come forward with emergency funding so that we can cancel the cuts, maintain vital services and build the council homes we desperately need.”
Since the May local elections, Lambeth council has been run by a minority Green Party administration, which relies on votes from Liberal Democrat members to approve policy. Labour lost control of the borough for the first time in 20 years after a number of housing scandals, including the Housing Ombudsman in 2023 accusing the town hall of “severe maladministration”.
In his 2022 review, Sir Bob, the former head of the civil service, said “feedback was uniformly negative” from council tenants and those living on estates earmarked for development had cited inconsistent policy, delays and poor communication. “As a consequence, levels of trust in the council are exceptionally low,” he added.
Next steps
A report, due to be discussed on Wednesday, states that £59 million in loans from Lambeth council to HfL have effectively already been written off and that another £9 million will likely need to be.
Next week, councillors will discuss winding down three of HfL’s four departments. The fourth, the company’s landlord arm HfL Homes, will remain in the short term “pending a broader review”. Officers said this was because it had a “considerable portfolio of properties which are tenanted and there may be wider benefits to the council from retaining a registered provider”.
Simon Cordon, the Lib Dem chair of the council’s housing scrutiny committee, said the reasons for “keeping HfL Homes afloat are a mystery”, adding that “the chances of it going terribly wrong are as close to certain as anything can be”.
Chris Nicholson, Lib Dem councillor and chair of Lambeth’s Finance and Budget Scrutiny Committee, said: “This report highlights the huge cost which the disastrous HfL project has had for Lambeth council taxpayers.
“I highlighted this cost a year ago and am pleased to see that council officers have now confirmed that we were correct.
“This means that for each of the next four years Lambeth taxpayers will be paying 10% higher council tax than they would have had to if it were not for this disastrous project by the previous Labour administration.”
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government was contacted for comment.