Unite has accused Birmingham City Council of trying to 'break' the bin strikes after analysis revealed the council doubled spending on agency staff since the start of the year-long industrial action. The Guardian's analysis of council spending data shows expenditure on agency staff in fleet and waste operations rose from £4.3m between April and December 2024 to more than £8.8m in the same period in 2025.
Birmingham's bin workers have been on all-out strike since March 2025 over proposed pay cuts and role changes, leaving residents without a fully functioning waste collection service. The council spent an average of £481,000 a month on agency staff in the nine months before strikes began in January 2025, which increased to £971,000 in January and over £1.2m in March 2025.
The Labour-run council strongly refuted 'any suggestion that agency workers have been carrying out work normally undertaken by striking workers', which is unlawful. It said it was using the 'same level of agency staff as before the strike' and that the figures cover the entire waste service, not just residential collections affected by industrial action.
Unite's general secretary, Sharon Graham, accused the council of 'breaking the law by using agency staff to try to break the strike'. She said: 'The council continually denied it but the figures here, that the Guardian have exposed, show the truth. The facts are clear. The council needs to stop wasting Birmingham residents' money trying to break the strike and instead resolve the strike.'
Mark Stuart, professor of employment relations at the University of Leeds, said the case hinges on what the increased expenditure was for. He noted that for the union, the doubled spending offers 'at least some basis for legal challenge'. The council and Unite were in negotiations last summer but talks broke down in July, with the council claiming it had reached 'the absolute limit of what we can offer'.
In December, agency workers joined picket lines for the first time over claims of bullying and harassment. Unite, fined £265,000 for breaching an injunction earlier this month, has said strikes could last beyond September 2026.