Tobacco firms accused of intimidation tactics to silence critics
Tobacco firms accused of intimidation tactics to silence critics

A report published in the journal Tobacco Control accuses the tobacco industry of using threats and complaints to employers as a tactic to push back against advocates, researchers and policymakers. The paper describes this as “a deliberate strategy to silence critics, distort evidence, and weaken regulation”.

The report, led by Australian physician and epidemiologist Prof Emily Banks, says complaints to employers of tobacco control advocates are “not isolated incidents but part of a systemic challenge”. While it is not possible to establish tobacco industry involvement with certainty in all cases of intimidation, the paper says working in tobacco control exposes researchers to a range of intimidation tactics and calls on governments and employers to treat intimidation as an occupational health and safety issue.

Researchers describe abuse and complaints

Prof Charlotta Pisinger, a medical doctor and public health researcher, described her experiences of intimidation by the tobacco industry. The Danish subsidiary of Philip Morris International (PMI) filed a complaint accusing her of breaching the University of Southern Denmark's research communication standards for media interviews she gave questioning the safety of heated tobacco and vapes. The complaint stated: “Pisinger claims that PMI lies and deceives. We assume that Pisinger's statements are to be understood polemically and not as an expression of a factual legal matter.”

The company also accused her of failing to clarify whether her comments reflected her scientific expertise or personal opinion, and of overstating conclusions and omitting context in her media appearances. Pisinger, who says a tobacco company demanded she be fired from the hospital she worked at in 2013, said “every time” her employer receives a complaint, “I have to explain myself, provide documentation, and so on”. She added: “It is time-consuming and unpleasant until it is resolved.”

Other intimidation tactics outlined

Other tactics mentioned in the paper include public and online discreditation, with tobacco researchers being labelled as “zealots” and “extremists” while their work is misrepresented; being the target of freedom of information requests; and legal threats. The paper also offers practical strategies for people to anticipate, withstand and learn from pushback.

Banks says she has felt intimidated when she was abused online or when people have contacted her boss “and that person's boss up the line to question the way I'm working”. She added: “Of course people have the right to seek information, but our paper finds that freedom of information requests can be weaponised for industry intimidation.”

Front groups and closed-door hearings

The paper accuses the tobacco industry of using clandestine tactics, operating through front groups and third parties, or using individuals and organisations whose affiliations are deliberately obscured. It argues that otherwise legitimate actions are used in ways that disproportionately burden, discredit or deter those targeted.

Associate professor Raglan Maddox from the Australian National University, a co-author of the paper, says “the most abuse I have ever received in one day” came after he spoke publicly about the health of children being a human right during an inquiry into vaping. He said: “The abuse I copped for 24 hours after that was phenomenal. Why would [the abusers] be questioning the way I look, my character, instead of an industry that continues to fuel 66 deaths a day in Australia, and 37% of all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander deaths?”

Maddox also called out the Australian parliamentary inquiry into illicit tobacco, where public health experts testified publicly, while tobacco industry figures were permitted to give evidence behind closed doors and remain anonymous. He said: “While they stood in the same hallways as us, the public accountability … is very different. They're protected from that scrutiny, and health practitioners don't have that same privilege.”

Impact on researchers and calls for action

The paper describes the toll responding to and preventing intimidation takes on workers. Lotus Sofie Bast, from the National Institute of Public Health in Denmark, researches tobacco and nicotine prevention among adolescents and says she is concerned by the tobacco industry's impact on young researchers in particular, who may be deterred from working in the field. She says she and her legal department “spend hours” responding to freedom of information requests from the industry, and that representatives have also shown up at student PhD defences taking notes and wearing sunglasses inside.

At an event to launch data about youth nicotine use, the tobacco industry fought with her institute to be allowed to attend. In the end, Bast counted about 15 tobacco, nicotine and e-cigarette industry representatives in the room. She said: “There was kind of an odd feeling in the room, and comments from other participants were rather sparse.”

When questioned about Pisinger's claims, a manager of corporate affairs for PMI in Denmark said the company “respects the right of academics to express their views, including views critical of our company”. The manager added: “Equally, we believe that claims presented as scientific fact should be open to scrutiny and challenge. Our complaint … does not seek to restrict [Pisinger's] freedom to speak or participate in public debate.”

The paper calls on employers to support staff through complaints, and on governments to more strictly enforce rules barring tobacco industry interference in health policy. It also outlines protective strategies for those working in the field, such as having a risk management plan, strengthening digital security, and documenting and reporting all threats. The paper concludes: “For those in tobacco control, the legacy will not be the attacks they endured, but the collective progress they helped secure.”