Health Secretary insists Grampian hospitals 'safe' after surgeon's 'slaughterhouse' claims
Health Secretary insists Grampian hospitals 'safe' after surgeon's claims

Scotland's Health Secretary Angela Constance has said that two hospitals in NHS Grampian are safe after a whistleblowing surgeon called for the health board to face a corporate homicide investigation. Dr Mohammed Meer Habib, a surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI), claimed hundreds of patients may have suffered “significant harm or avoidable deaths” in recent years. Constance also said she only became aware of Dr Habib's correspondence on Thursday, the day he went public with his concerns.

Surgeon's review findings

On Thursday, Dr Habib shared the findings of a review, instructed by NHS Grampian in September 2022, of 45 liver and pancreatic surgery cases. The review found that there were 19 avoidable deaths among the 31 who died between 2015 and 2021. It came a week after the publication of a damning report about NHS Grampian, following which Constance said a specialist team has been sent in to NHS Grampian to provide “intensive turnaround support”.

The report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland found “serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across the acute sector of NHS Grampian”. In an interview on BBC Radio Scotland's Breakfast programme on Friday, Constance was asked whether she stands by her comment last week that patients at ARI and Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin are safe. She replied: “I do.”

Health Secretary's response

She added: “I want immediate action and improvements, but it also has to be sustained for the longer term, and that is why additional people on the ground have been put in place in NHS Grampian to support the new chair, to support the new people that will be coming into the board, to support those that are newly appointed to a range of positions in terms of clinical governance, because there must be that oversight, that scrutiny, as well as the support.”

Dr Habib formally raised concerns about “excessive mortality in surgery” in July 2021, which he said related to what he believes to be “dozens of avoidable deaths”. He contacted Police Scotland about the deaths in 2024, and the following year wrote to the Lord Advocate. The surgeon said he also contacted the First Minister and Health Secretary in June 2023, October 2024, November 2025 and May 2026 but was told the Scottish Government had no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing and individual boards.

Police and NHS Grampian statements

Police Scotland have said they are investigating. Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths. Inquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

Constance said it was only on Thursday that she became aware of Dr Habib's correspondence. Asked how that could be, she said: “It is current practice that where individuals or any member of the public, if they write in with detailed questions that are very specific around for example, clinical questions, that that would go to the appropriate team. But it's also important to highlight again to your listeners that the First Minister has asked the permanent secretary to review our internal process, and the permanent secretary will do that, I'm sure, with pace, to see what, if any, changes need to take place.”

She said that steps were taken in relation to every piece of correspondence from Dr Habib. The Health Secretary said she will also hold discussions with NHS Grampian around the “very legitimate questions” around why the 2022 report was not published. Constance said that she still has confidence in the NHS Grampian chief executive, saying “I do, because the history of some of the very distressing issues predates her appointment.”

In a statement on Thursday, Laura Skaife-Knight, the chief executive of NHS Grampian, said: “We are aware of the serious allegations raised today. A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing. Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes. We understand the allegations will cause further concern to patients, members of the public and staff. It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed. This includes direct communication with patients and families where required. If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so. Patient safety remains our highest priority.”

A spokesperson for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) said: “The concerns raised by Dr Habib were taken seriously by COPFS, with confirmation from Police Scotland that an inquiry was under way. Given the complexity and breadth of the issues raised, inquiries remain ongoing.”