Surgeon Mohammed Meer Habib has accused NHS Grampian bosses of covering up avoidable deaths and called for them to face a corporate homicide investigation. The practising Aberdeen Royal Infirmary consultant said he had been left with no choice but to put his 36-year career on the line after repeated attempts to whistleblow on patient safety failed.
Career on the line
Dr Habib, a consultant in Hepatopancreatobiliary who has worked at ARI for more than a decade, spoke out after a damning Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) report into the health board, which criticised culture, leadership, and governance. He said multiple patients died in the operating theatre or following surgery from avoidable deaths, with families kept in the dark. He first tried to raise concerns 10 years ago but failings continued.
Dr Habib said: "I know that today I am putting my career on the line to demand accountability and for the public to know the full extent of this cover up. I have tried my very best to use the procedures, to go to every institution but they all failed to act robustly as they should have, failing to investigate or take the appropriate precautions. I believe that NHS Grampian should face an investigation for Corporate Homicide."
Systemic failures identified
The HIS report identified systemic issues and recurring weaknesses, including a loss of confidence in management to deliver reliable and consistent information after Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin continued to operate on children despite an order to halt all paediatric surgery. Serious weaknesses in leadership and management of the medical workforce across NHS Grampian were identified, including a lack of workforce plans, poor recruitment controls, and major concerns in the management of doctors. There were also concerns of staff not working well together and a failure to fix patient safety problems.
Medical director at HIS, Dr Simon Watson, said the findings were "unprecedented" and described the report as "the most serious review" the healthcare watchdog had ever written. On Tuesday, Health Secretary Angela Constance said the health board would not be escalated to stage five - the highest level of government intervention - but it remains a possibility.
Legal and political response
Dr Habib spoke alongside his lawyer Aamer Anwar at a press conference on Thursday, who said his account exposed "a cover up on an industrial scale" at NHS Grampian and measures put in place by Constance do not go far enough. Mr Anwar said: "Catastrophically, the operation theatre he worked in, at times could be described as a 'slaughterhouse', which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability. The measures unveiled by Angela Constance fail to deal with a deep-rooted culture of denial, arrogance and incompetence."
The surgeon said he began to raise concerns from 2016 on mortality rate. A report shows a review was instructed in September 2022 by HIS. It reviewed 45 cases, concluding 19 were avoidable deaths. But the medic claims avoidable deaths continued to happen and some patients received the wrong operations and died, whilst their families were not told why.
Ongoing concerns and next steps
Dr Habib said he contacted the First Minister and Cabinet Secretary in writing in June 2023, then again in October 2024, November 2025 and May 2026. He said he received a response each time from a civil servant, stating the Scottish Government had no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing cases in individual boards. He was referred to the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer (INWO) and Police Scotland. The surgeon said that in November last year, INWO refused to progress his complaints on the basis that they were either 'time barred' and 'pre-dated the National Whistleblowing Standards'.
The surgeon said he reported 20 cases of possible culpable homicide at ARI to Police Scotland in 2024 and has been interviewed several times. He said: "Two examples of a Corporate Homicide case are where patients were advised they would be operated on for a certain procedure, but instead they were wrongly operated on for an entirely different matter and they died - their families were not informed of the mistakes. I believe the reality of poor outcomes was concealed. They are holding the key to the Pandora's box and I believe they are deliberately and manipulatively not opening the box. In every other death at the hands of the state, families would be entitled to understand that circumstances of their loved ones death, we can't 'draw a line in the sand' as Angela Constance has said, families deserve to know how and why their loved one died."
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight has said she recognises the seriousness of the report and apologised to patients and staff for failings. She previously said: "As a board, we own this, we accept the findings and are now absolutely determined to put this right." She said she had commissioned the external assessment in May to examine clinical governance.