The Girl in the Picture, a 2022 Netflix documentary, has been called one of the most bone-chilling shows on the platform, and it lives up to that reputation.
Directed by Skye Borgman, known for Abducted in Plain Sight, the film follows the harrowing account of a young girl who was abducted. Based on the books A Beautiful Child and Finding Sharon, it revisits a 1990 mystery when a young woman is found dying by the side of an Oklahoma road after a suspicious hit-and-run.
The Story of Sharon Marshall
Sharon Marshall was kidnapped and raised by a man named Franklin Delano Floyd. Over two decades, she was raised as his daughter and later died in a suspicious hit-and-run accident in 1990.
The documentary takes viewers into Sharon's life, and the narrative proves deeply haunting. Going in blind, one viewer reported shivers down the spine and unsettling dreams that evening.
Viewer Reactions and Critical Response
A synopsis reads: "A young mother’s mysterious death and her son’s subsequent kidnapping blow open a decades-long mystery about the woman’s true identity, and the murderous federal fugitive at the center of it all."
Viewers have shared strong reactions online. One Reddit user posted: "This one haunts me. I’m scarred for life." Another wrote: "One of my absolute favourites! I was ugly crying watching the last episode (at the cemetary). I guess I was so sad for what could have been because in alternate universe, girl in the picture could have had a totally awesome life."
A third admitted: "I saw it when it came out. Im still processing it," while a fourth echoed: "I saw years ago, and I am still processing it. I don’t think I’ll ever be reminded of this without getting a chill down my spine. Her fate made me question my spirituality…."
With a Rotten Tomatoes score of 96%, one reviewer said: "This documentary was one of the most bone chilling docs I have ever watched. It made me sad, angry and scared all in one." Another added: "One of the best true crime docs I have seen. It's just so twisted."
Where to Watch
It is definitely one to watch, but be warned - it will likely leave you utterly horrified and a bit terrified. The Girl in the Picture can be streamed on Netflix.