Prime Video viewers are ditching the new drama series Every Year After, with many calling it 'painful to watch' just three episodes in. The adaptation, based on Carley Fortune's beloved novel Every Summer After, has sparked widespread disappointment among fans of the original book.
Plot and Premise
The series follows 28-year-old obituary writer Percy Fraser, played by Sadie Soverall, as she is forced to confront her troubled past. Percy spent her childhood summers in the lakeside town of Barry's Bay, where she formed close bonds with brothers Sam (Matt Cornett) and Charlie (Michael Bradway). A romance with Sam developed, but she abruptly left the Bay and refused to return. The dark truth behind her sudden exit unfolds gradually throughout the season.
Viewer Reactions
While some viewers are captivated, those familiar with the book have expressed frustration. On Reddit, one viewer admitted, "I'm considering jumping ship and I'm on episode 3. I'm MAD." They added, "There are just too many shallow and pointless things being thrown at something that could have been simply done on a plot/book that was FLAWLESS. I so wish this was just a movie instead."
Another disappointed fan wrote: "So many totally unnecessary changes... I'm actually angry watching it." A third said, "Every plot point from the book was messed up."
Key Changes from the Book
The adaptation makes notable departures from Fortune's original novel. A major change involves how Sam learns about Percy's intimacy with his brother Charlie. In the TV version, Percy reveals the truth upon returning to Barry's Bay after a decade. In the book, Charlie confesses years before Percy returns.
Mixed Reviews
Despite the backlash, some viewers have praised the series. One review noted, "Having read the book, I still found the show to be a delightful summer must-watch." Another fan declared, "Such a dreamy and expansive ode to Percy and Sam's story. Loved every second!"
Every Year After is streaming now on Prime Video.
