Strictly Come Dancing judge Craig Revel Horwood has defended his criticism of two professional dancers, insisting their choreography broke the rules of the named dance. During Saturday's (November 14) live show, the remaining couples competed for a place in next week's Blackpool special.
Foxtrot Dispute
Lacey Turner and Vito Coppola performed a Foxtrot to Have You Met Miss Jones? by Robbie Williams, but Craig was unimpressed, arguing the routine resembled an American Smooth rather than a Foxtrot.
"It wasn't a Foxtrot so I don't know how we're meant to judge that," he said. "Foxtrot is not an open dance. You could have saved this for an American Smooth."
Vito challenged the judge, saying: "Rules say 70 per cent should be Foxtrot, 30 per cent is open, so I literally did not break the rules."
Judges Respond on Lights Up
Craig doubled down during Sunday's (November 15) edition of Strictly: Lights Up, hosted by Abi Clarke and Tyler West. When Tyler asked why he had become "such a stickler for the rules all of a sudden," Craig replied: "I have because putting four or five lifts into a routine that is meant to be danced on the floor, and also, we want to see a Foxtrot, not an American Smooth. I'm sorry. Look, it's up to them, they can do whatever they like... But our marks will reflect [that] they haven't done it."
Addressing Nikita Kuzmin's choreography from Saturday night, Craig added: "So, yeah, you can go for all the splashy, showbiz lifts you want, and your celebrity's feet might not even touch the floor once." Tyler then asked if it was harsh that the celebrity suffers from that, to which Craig responded: "No," before adding: "Vito's argument was that he was making his celeb look great, and that's fine. She did look great, she looked great doing all the open work, fabulous. But we got about 10 seconds of Foxtrot. That's [like] me saying, 'Oh right, you're doing the Charleston, but you're going to come out doing the Argentine bleeding Tango!' No, no, no."
Motsi Mabuse added: "If you do a Foxtrot, it's much more difficult. It's a dance, dancing together with the partner with the technique, and, you know, it's easier to just put lifts and flash this, and put a spin, and all that. It wouldn't be fair to the other couples that are following the rules. So, we need to stand there as judges [and] decide what we are going to judge, you know. And if it says Foxtrot, I don't need to question the dance. I don't need to look up like, 'Where is the Foxtrot?'"
Anton Du Beke said: "I've done it myself many times over the years. It's not okay if you're trying to get away with it, if you go, 'Oh no, no, it was a Foxtrot.' You've got to accept the responsibility." Shirley Ballas noted that Vito "did take the responsibility on himself," before Anton added: "I think he's got to do that before. You've got to know what you're trying to achieve here."
Results Show and Elimination
Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe and Johannes Radebe returned to host the results show on Sunday. Jaime Winstone and Carlos Gu faced Will Best and Dianne Buswell in the dance-off.
Will and Dianne performed a Paso Doble to Smalltown Boy by Bronski Beat, while Jaime and Carlos danced a Charleston to I Can't Do It Alone by Catherine Zeta-Jones. Motsi and Shirley voted to save Jaime and Carlos, Anton chose Will and Dianne, and Craig's casting vote saved Jaime and Carlos, eliminating Will and Dianne.
Strictly Come Dancing is available to stream on BBC iPlayer.