Ella Bruccoleri delivers a lovely performance as Mary Bennet in the new BBC adaptation of Janice Hadlow's novel The Other Bennet Sister. However, the series has been criticised for overemphasising jokes about Mary's poor marriage prospects, which some reviewers have found tiresome.
The 10-part series, adapted by Sarah Quintrell with additional writing by Maddie Dai, opens with the familiar scene of Mrs Bennet (Ruth Jones) excitedly announcing the arrival of Mr Bingley at Netherfield Park. While her sisters Jane, Elizabeth, Lydia and Kitty react in their characteristic ways, Mary is ignored despite her attempts to engage in conversation. Her plain appearance and bookish nature are repeatedly mocked by her family, a theme that dominates the early episodes.
Critics have noted that the relentless focus on Mary's perceived unmarriageability becomes absurd and boring. Even when Mary attracts the attention of the kind Mr Sparrow (Aaron Gill), an optician who appreciates her intelligence, Mrs Bennet sabotages the match, fearing it will harm the prospects of her other daughters. Ruth Jones's performance as Mrs Bennet has been described as outsized, even for a broad production.
The series improves when Mary is sent away to work as a governess, allowing her character to develop beyond the family's scorn. Despite its flaws, the adaptation offers a fresh perspective on a lesser-known Bennet sister, though some feel it is too slight for its Sunday evening slot.