MasterChef, one of the BBC's most successful shows, is in disarray after a tumultuous fortnight that led to the departure of both its presenters, Gregg Wallace and John Torode. The crisis began when Wallace posted a five-page statement on social media, admitting to using inappropriate language but claiming he had been cleared of the most serious allegations. He also revealed a recent autism diagnosis and complained of an 'incredible injustice'.
Producers Banijay had been celebrating the show's move to new studios in Birmingham when Wallace's post triggered a chain of events. At a dinner for top executives, Banijay boss Patrick Holland emphasised the work behind a lawyer-led report into allegations against Wallace. The report, released on Monday, substantiated 45 allegations against Wallace. Torode was also the subject of a substantiated complaint over racist language, which he denies. Richard Osman revealed on his podcast that Torode was accused of using 'the worst racial slur there is', reportedly while repeating lyrics from a Kanye West song at an after-work gathering.
BBC bosses concluded Wallace could not change his behaviour and wrote to him accordingly. Banijay and the BBC opted not to renew Torode's contract, though he will appear in already-filmed Christmas specials. TV critic Scott Bryan called it a 'complete mess', noting the shock of losing two presenters so quickly. He sees it as an opportunity for a fresh start with new judges.
Despite the crisis, the show's long-term status seems secure. MasterChef remains a global powerhouse, with over 60 versions launched worldwide and four new adaptations in 2024 alone. It is a major money-spinner, including a line of kitchenware. For the BBC, it is a cornerstone of schedules, with some version of the show airing most weeks. BBC director general Tim Davie has backed the show, which is tied to production until 2028, and the move to Birmingham supports claims of driving jobs outside London.
Insiders say a radical rebrand is unnecessary, as the format's popularity has never been in question. Producers are now tasked with finding new judges to maintain the show's appeal while navigating the fallout from the scandal.
