Showbiz editor Jess Phillips, with over five years in the industry, has compiled a list of the worst daytime television presenters currently on air. Drawing from extensive viewing—mostly for work, with about 10% in waiting rooms—Phillips argues that the current lineup lacks the charisma of earlier stars.
Lorraine Kelly: Too Saccharine and Faux
Phillips criticises Lorraine Kelly, whose show has been cut from an hour to 30 minutes and from 52 weeks to 30 per year. Despite Kelly insisting she will retire only when everyone is "fed up," Phillips believes that time has passed. She describes Kelly as "too saccharine," with a false enthusiasm for every guest. When Kelly dislikes someone, such as Kim Woodburn, the contempt shows despite a fixed grin, creating an "uncanny valley" effect.
Andi Peters: Paid to Be on Holiday
Andi Peters is accused of "stealing a living," presenting the same ITV competition rules from exotic locations. Phillips notes that Peters has hit out at complaints he is "paid to be on holiday" while sipping a cocktail on a beach in Cyprus. She argues a child could do his five-minute segment from a bedroom, saving the network money.
Ben Shephard and Cat Deeley: Lacking Chemistry
Phillips pines for the days of Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield, calling current This Morning hosts Ben Shephard and Cat Deeley "about as charismatic as plain rice." She praises Dermot O'Leary and Alison Hammond for their engaging segments, but finds Shephard and Deeley merely "competent." Phillips says viral clips of the show rarely feature them, and suggests the programme is struggling without a full change.
Janet Street-Porter: Endless Moaning
Janet Street-Porter is singled out on Loose Women for her constant negativity. Phillips notes controversies including branding Wales as "grey" and its language "incomprehensible," comparing microchipping children to Nazi tattoos, and blaming Toby Carvery for rising obesity. Phillips concludes, "The woman's after your Sunday roast."
