An American living in the UK has caused a stir by brutally dismissing Oasis' live performances as "rubbish"—and fans are not having it.
The expat, who remains unnamed, took to social media to share their controversial opinion, claiming the iconic Britpop band were "overrated" and "messy" on stage. The comments have since gone viral, with die-hard Oasis supporters firing back in defence of Liam and Noel Gallagher's legendary gigs.
"They Were a Shambles Live"
"Let’s be honest, Oasis were a shambles live," the critic wrote. "Noel was the only one who could actually sing, and even then, it was hit or miss."
The remarks have divided music lovers, with some agreeing that the band’s rowdy, chaotic energy wasn’t for everyone—while others insist their raw, unfiltered performances were what made them iconic.
Fans Clap Back
Oasis loyalists quickly flooded the comments, with one fan snapping: "If you didn’t get it, you never will." Another added: "Their gigs were electric—you just had to be there."
Despite the backlash, the American stood their ground, doubling down: "Nostalgia blinds people. They were sloppy, and Liam’s voice was shot after the first album."
Could this fiery debate reignite talks of an Oasis reunion? Or will it only fuel the Gallagher brothers' infamous feud? One thing’s for sure—Britpop fans are not staying quiet.
