A Canadian library has faced criticism for allowing a feminist with controversial views on transgender rights to hold an event, sparking protests and a debate over free speech. Hundreds gathered outside the Toronto Public Library branch as writer Meghan Murphy gave a talk on gender identity and its impact on women's rights.
The library defended its decision, citing its obligation to protect free speech. City librarian Vickery Bowles stated that while the library supports the LGBT community, the event did not violate rental policies as Murphy has never been convicted of hate speech. PEN Canada supported the decision, but opponents, including Toronto Mayor John Tory, condemned it.
Murphy argues that transgender activism undermines women's safe spaces, such as prisons and refuges, and says she believes the movement is 'regressive and sexist'. Critics, including Professor Judith Taylor from the University of Toronto, label her a provocateur who sidelines transgender rights. Pride Toronto warned of consequences to its relationship with the library.
An online petition calling for the event's cancellation garnered over 8,000 signatures, and two city councillors have called for a review of policies on community space use. The incident follows similar controversy in Vancouver, where the library was barred from the city's pride parade after hosting a talk involving Murphy.
Murphy has also spoken at the Scottish Parliament on transgender issues and was banned from Twitter for stating that 'men aren't women'. She has taken legal action against the company.
