Strictly Come Dancing's first live show of the new series averaged 4.8 million viewers on BBC One, a drop from the 6.2 million average recorded for the 2025 live show. The programme peaked at five million viewers on Saturday night.
The BBC had to make significant changes this year after Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman stepped down as presenters. Emma Willis, Johannes Radebe, and Josh Widdicombe have taken over presenting duties, but the move to a three-person format has drawn criticism.
Fans complain about busy format
A common complaint among fans is that the show feels too busy, confusing, and long-winded. The previous duo had a tried-and-tested formula: Tess commanded the main stage, keeping the show flowing and speaking with judges and contestants about scores, while Claudia led post-dance chats on the dance floor, delving into the emotional side of the competition.
With three presenters, the format feels more awkward and clunky, with no clear structure. Questions have been raised about whether Emma will always be on the main floor or if the three will swap roles, and whether a second presenter is needed when one is already speaking to the four judges.
Josh Widdicombe faces backlash
Josh Widdicombe has faced the most backlash, despite his efforts. Emma has significant experience as a live TV presenter on Celebrity Big Brother, and Johannes had been a dancer on Strictly for seven years before moving into his new role. Josh, a comedian with no dance experience, is best known for game shows, radio, and podcasts.
It was clear before the season started that he might have a tougher time settling in. The BBC was aware that the three-presenter format had been widely scrutinised, but it ignored the noise. Producers should have worked out how the three hosts could be best utilised or given their own distinct roles, so no one felt like a spare part.
The broadcaster failed to listen to viewers and left Josh to deal with the fallout. It remains to be seen whether the BBC will adjust the format in response to the criticism.
